Studio Legale Mariani
EN
Contact

Immigration case lawSupreme courts · Courts of merit · European Courts

Immigration case-law review no. 1, 26 October 2026

Studio Legale MarianiPeriod covered: 12-26 October 2026Updated to 26.10.2026
Archived contribution. The review reflects the legislation and case law known on the date indicated and is not updated. Before relying on it in a specific case, the official text in force today should be consulted.

Introduction

This issue opens the review devoted to immigration law, which accompanies the general weekly legal review of the Legal Watch. It collects the rulings of the Court of Cassation and of the courts of merit, the decisions of the higher Courts and the measures of the administrative courts made known during the period, on international protection, border procedures, expulsion and detention, entry for work, social benefits and equal treatment. Each case note gives the authority, number and date and, where the text is published in an official database, the link to the source; it is drafted after reading the full text of the decision; the parties are never named, and personal data are omitted even where the decision contains them.

The first issue covers the two weeks from 12 to 26 October 2026.

Three rulings of the supreme courts are accompanied by a signed commentary: orders no. 24437 and no. 22869 of 2026 of the Court of Cassation, on expulsion, and interlocutory order no. 27395 of 2026, on the top-up to the minimum of pensions under the international system. On orders nos. 175 and 176 of 2026 of the Constitutional Court, the commentary of 24 October 2026 remains available.

In brief

The rulings of the period share a common thread: the passing of time and the conduct of the administration cannot be borne by the foreign national. The Court of Rome and the Court of Milan hold that the regime applicable to an asylum application is determined by the date on which the wish to apply is expressed and not by the date of its formalisation, which depends on the offices; the T.A.R. (Regional Administrative Court) for Campania suspends the revocation of a work clearance (nulla osta) that came almost four years later; the T.A.R. for Veneto allows a new employer to take over when the employer who had applied for the clearance cannot be traced. The Court of Cassation restates that the justice of the peace, when ruling on expulsion, must assess the foreign national's current situation, their actual dangerousness and subsequent facts, such as an application for protection. As regards the European Pact, the Court of Palermo raises a question of constitutional legitimacy on the «fiction of non-entry» in border procedures, and the Court of Naples excludes the border procedure where the applicant's health conditions have not been checked. Finally, the Constitutional Court is awaiting the Court of Justice on the employment requirement for social housing.

Supreme courts and higher Courts

Expulsion and subsequent application for protection. Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 24437 del 2026

References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 24437, published on 4 August 2026, R.G. no. 24968/2025, President Acierno, Judge Rapporteur Scalia; recorded in the Court's official database SentenzeWeb, with the identifying data redacted as ordered in the decision.

The facts. The Justice of the Peace of Ragusa had upheld an expulsion decree relying solely on the «information sheet» drawn up when the person was traced, without considering that, in the meantime, the foreign national had applied for international protection and obtained the related provisional permit.

The principle. The Court upholds both grounds and sets the decision aside with referral, holding that «The receipt of the application for international protection constitutes a provisional residence permit, which gives the applicant the right to remain in the territory of the State until the proceedings are concluded» and that the justice of the peace «had to verify whether the conditions for expulsion still existed at the time of the decision».

Practical implications. In proceedings challenging expulsion, facts that arise after the decree must always be pleaded and documented, starting with the asylum application and the provisional permit: a court that ignores them gives merely apparent reasoning and breaches art. 4 of d.lgs. n. 142 del 2015 and art. 19 of the Consolidated Immigration Act.

The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →

Expulsion and social dangerousness. Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 22869 del 2026

References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 22869, published on 7 July 2026, R.G. no. 23737/2025, President Acierno, Judge Rapporteur Caiazzo; full text on SentenzeWeb.

The facts. The Justice of the Peace of Bari had dismissed the challenge to an expulsion decree based solely on previous drug offences, without considering the rehabilitation path followed by the foreign national while serving the sentence.

The principle. Referring to its own precedents (Cass. n. 23597 del 2023 and n. 19672 del 2025), the Court restates that social dangerousness «must instead be established in concrete terms and as of the present time», with a «reasonable and proportionate balancing of the interests involved», and sets the judgment aside because the justice of the peace had presumed it from the criminal record, «without carrying out a current and concrete assessment».

Practical implications. Documentation of the path followed in prison and after release, work, training, leave permits, reports by the social services, is decisive evidence against expulsions based on automatic assumptions.

The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →

Social housing and employment requirement. Corte cost., ordd. nn. 175 e 176 del 2026

References. Constitutional Court, order no. 175 of 2026, decided on 8 July and filed on 22 October 2026 (official record), and order no. 176 of 2026, filed on the same day (official record); President Amoroso, drafting judge Navarretta.

The principle. In the first order the Court asks the Court of Justice whether the intention to derogate from the equal treatment provided for by art. 12 of Directive 2011/98/EU must appear expressly in the implementing text or may be inferred from the explanatory report; in the second it also adjourns to a later date the proceedings brought by the Court of Milan on art. 40, comma 6, of the Consolidated Immigration Act and on Lombardy Regional Law no. 16 of 2016.

Practical implications. Exclusions from rankings based solely on the lack of a current job should be challenged without letting the time limits expire. On this topic, see the commentary of 24 October 2026.

Pension under the international system and top-up to the minimum. Cass. civ., sez. lav., ord. interl. n. 27395 del 2026

References. Court of Cassation, Labour Section, interlocutory order no. 27395 of 20 October 2026, President Esposito, Judge Rapporteur Magnanensi (official record).

The principle. The Court asks the Court of Justice whether art. 58 of Regulation (EC) no. 883/2004 requires an independent foreign benefit to be added to the Italian pension calculated on an international pro rata basis in order to determine entitlement to the top-up to the minimum.

Practical implications. Workers whose contribution records are split between several States should not allow decisions revoking or refusing the top-up to become final while awaiting the answer from Luxembourg.

The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →

Persecution for political opinion and sur place protection. The Massimario's review

On 23 October 2026 the Massimario and Docket Office (Ufficio del Massimario e del Ruolo) of the Court of Cassation published a thematic review of case law on international and complementary protection, devoted to persecution for political opinion and to sur place protection, that is, protection based on facts arising after departure from the country of origin. It is a useful reference for appeals that rely on political activity carried out in Italy.

Case law of the courts of merit

Transitional regime of the Pact and date of the asylum application. Court of Rome, 29 September and 13 October 2026

References. Court of Rome, Section for personal rights and immigration, judgment of 29 September 2026, R.G. no. 24772/2026, and judgment no. 14179 published on 13 October 2026, R.G. no. 25435/2026.

The facts. Two people had tried several times, in April 2026, to gain access to the Immigration Office of the Rome police headquarters (Questura) and had then expressed by p.e.c. (certified e-mail) their wish to apply for asylum; the Questura had replied that appointments were reserved for certified vulnerabilities.

The principle. The second judgment observes that giving exclusive weight to formalisation «would allow the administration [...] to determine unilaterally the applicable legal regime», and that in art. 17, comma 4, of d.l. n. 100 del 2026 «the use of the term "lodging" rules out that it may be regarded as a synonym of "formalisation"». Both judgments order the Ministry of the Interior to formalise the applications; the second declares the application subject to Directive 2013/32/EU.

Practical implications. The date on which the wish to apply was expressed should be documented and proven in every proceeding. On this topic, see the commentary of 26 October 2026.

The same principle and safe countries of origin. Court of Milan, decree of 29 September 2026

References. Court of Milan, Specialised Immigration Section, decree of 29 September 2026 in proceedings R.G. no. 31896-1/2026, Judge Minieri.

The facts. An Egyptian national had expressed the wish to apply for protection on 17 February 2026, as shown by the record of the withdrawal of his passport, but the application was formalised only on 22 June; the Territorial Commission, applying the new regulation, had declared it manifestly unfounded in an accelerated procedure.

The principle. The Court holds that the abnormal lapse of time between expression and formalisation, beyond the applicant's control, cannot be held against him in malam partem; it therefore applies the previous rules and, in the light of the case law of the Court of Justice on art. 37 of Directive 2013/32/EU, disapplies the designation of Egypt as a safe country of origin, restoring the ordinary procedure and suspending the effects of the refusal.

Practical implications. When the wish to apply was expressed before 12 June 2026, the whole structure of the procedure, accelerated or ordinary, time limits and suspension, must be re-examined under the previous rules.

Border procedures and the «fiction of non-entry». Court of Palermo, order of 13 October 2026

References. Court of Palermo, Specialised Immigration Section, order of 13 October 2026, Judge Guarnotta, on a complaint under art. 5-quinquies of d.lgs. n. 142 del 2015.

The facts. An Egyptian applicant subject to the border procedure had been ordered by the Prefect of Agrigento to reside exclusively in a reception centre. During the interview it emerged that he understood only Egyptian dialect and not the standard Arabic used by the interpreter.

The principle. The Court reinstates the complainant's time limit under art. 153, comma 2, c.p.c., suspends the residence obligation as an interim measure and raises a question of constitutional legitimacy concerning artt. 5-ter, 5-quater and 5-quinquies of d.lgs. n. 142 del 2015, with reference to artt. 2, 3 and 10, third paragraph, of the Constitution, insofar as they allow an applicant subject to the border procedure to be required to stay exclusively in a specified place, without being considered authorised to enter, even though «the person is physically present in the territory of the Republic and holds the constitutional right of asylum». The judge also invokes the doctrine of counter-limits (controlimiti), because the mechanism derives from the European Pact.

Practical implications. The question may be cited in complaints against residence obligations in border procedures; checking the language the applicant actually understands is a point to be addressed from the outset.

Border procedure and health conditions. Court of Naples, decree of 10 October 2026

References. Court of Naples, Thirteenth Civil Section, Specialised Immigration Section, decree of 10 October 2026 in proceedings R.G. no. 20983-1/2026, Judge Capone.

The facts. A Bangladeshi applicant, who landed after a search and rescue operation, had been subjected to the border procedure even though the screening form prescribed clinical monitoring and a specialist examination that were never carried out; the Territorial Commission had rejected the application as manifestly unfounded.

The principle. The Court considers that it must first verify, in the light of art. 53 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, the conditions for the border procedure; in the absence of proof that the health and procedural needs had been assessed, the ordinary procedure applies again, with the suspensive effect of the appeal provided for by art. 35-bis, comma 3, of d.lgs. n. 25 del 2008. The applicant is authorised to enter the territory and remain there until the outcome of the proceedings; the request for a permit pending asylum is, however, declared inadmissible under the applicable rules.

Practical implications. The screening form and the decision applying the border procedure should always be obtained and compared: any health need that was reported and not followed up is an argument for leaving the border procedure.

Special protection after the Cutro decree. Court of L'Aquila, decree of 28 September 2026

References. Court of L'Aquila, Specialised Immigration Section, decree of 28 September 2026, R.G. no. 2671/2024, honorary judge (G.O.P.) Palumbo.

The facts. A national of Bangladesh, who had left because of poverty and debts incurred to pay for his wife's medical treatment, had stated that he had been tortured and exploited at work in Libya, a transit country; in Italy he worked as a farm labourer on a fixed-term contract.

The principle. While applying the rules introduced after d.l. n. 20 del 2023, the Court observes that the first part of art. 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Immigration Act, with its reference to art. 5, comma 6, has remained unchanged, and cites Cass. n. 28162 del 2023: the right to respect for private and family life «continues to be protected by art. 8 ECHR». Having assessed the integration achieved and the vulnerability resulting from the torture suffered in the transit country, it grants special protection, even though Bangladesh is among the safe countries of origin.

Practical implications. Work, even seasonal or fixed-term, and violence suffered in transit remain decisive factors for special protection; they should be documented with contracts, payslips and certificates.

Social allowance and foreign income. Corte d'appello di Roma, sez. lav., sent. n. 3775 del 2026

References. Court of Appeal of Rome, Labour Section, judgment no. 3775 published on 24 September 2026, R.G. no. 2253/2025, President Anzilotti Nitto de' Rossi, Judge Rapporteur Trementozzi.

The facts. INPS (the National Social Security Institute) had rejected the application for the social allowance of an Egyptian national resident in Italy since 1992 for failure to prove the absence of income in the country of origin, even though a consular certificate had been produced; the Tribunal had upheld the refusal.

The principle. Reversing that decision, the Court holds that a foreign national who is lawfully staying and resident is taxed in Italy on all income, wherever produced, so that their position does not differ from that of an Italian citizen and they cannot be required to provide a specific certification of foreign income; it orders INPS to pay the arrears.

Practical implications. Refusals of the social allowance based solely on the lack of a foreign certification can be challenged, also in the light of the prohibition of discrimination.

Flows decree and takeover by a new employer. T.A.R. Veneto, sez. III, sent. n. 1777 del 2026

References. T.A.R. for Veneto, Third Section, judgment no. 1777 published on 8 September 2026, given under art. 60 c.p.a. (Code of Administrative Procedure) in appeal R.G. no. 1289/2026.

The facts. A Moroccan worker who entered on a seasonal work visa had never managed to contact the employer who had applied for the work clearance, and the Prefecture of Rovigo had refused the takeover by a new employer.

The principle. The T.A.R. annuls the refusal: a foreign national who entered lawfully and who, for reasons not attributable to him, was unable to start the employment relationship with the applying employer, but made efforts to find other work, «cannot be left without protection», as confirmed by art. 22, comma 6-bis, of the Consolidated Immigration Act, under which «Pending the signing of the residence contract, the clearance allows work to be carried out in the national territory».

Practical implications. Evidence of attempts to contact the original employer should be kept and the new job opportunity documented without delay.

Revocation of the work clearance after four years. T.A.R. Campania, sez. VI, interim order of 7 October 2026

References. T.A.R. for Campania, Sixth Section, interim order decided in chambers on 7 October 2026 in appeal R.G. no. 5491/2026, President Soricelli, Judge Rapporteur Vampa.

The facts. In July 2026 the Prefecture of Naples had revoked a seasonal work clearance issued in August 2022, also alleging failure to comply with the eight-day time limit for the summons, when the worker had by then found other jobs, including on a permanent contract.

The principle. The T.A.R. suspends the revocation, observing that the lapse of «an unusual spatium temporis, amounting to almost four years» is not attributable to the applicant and that the administration «appears to have unreasonably placed on the applicant the risk of the passing of time»; the hearing on the merits is set for 21 July 2027.

Practical implications. In late revocations of work clearances, the time elapsed and the lawful work carried out in the meantime are central arguments, already at the interim stage.

Notes

The case notes are for information purposes only and do not constitute legal advice on any specific case. Decisions of the courts of merit are rulings on individual cases, often interim, and are not binding precedents; their full text was read before each case note was drafted. Quotations from decisions are given in our English translation.

The review is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.

← Back to Immigration case law