The ruling
Court of Cassation (Corte di cassazione), First Civil Section, order no. 24437 of 2026, decided in chambers on 5 June 2026 and published on 4 August 2026, General Register (R.G.) no. 24968/2025. President ACIERNO, reporting judge SCALIA
“In proceedings challenging an expulsion decree, the court must assess the current situation of the foreign national at the time of the decision, taking into account facts that have arisen after the administrative measure; the making of an application for international protection and the issue of the related provisional permit under art. 4 D.Lgs. 142/2015 are facts that bar expulsion, constituting a legal ground of non-expellability, in application of art. 19 T.U.I. (Consolidated Immigration Act) and of the principle of non-refoulement laid down in art. 33 of the Geneva Convention.”
Principle of law stated at point 5 of the grounds for the decision. The Court ordered that the name and other identifying details of the applicant be omitted. The decision is recorded in the official SentenzeWeb database, where the anonymised text is being published.
The case
On 13 February 2024 the Prefect of Ragusa issued an expulsion decree with immediate escort to the border, followed by the Questore’s order to leave the national territory within seven days. The foreign national challenged it before the Justice of the Peace of Ragusa, who declared the proceedings extinguished under art. 181 c.p.c. (Code of Civil Procedure); the Court of Cassation, by order no. 16439 of 2025, quashed that decision, because extinction had been declared although its conditions were not met, in breach of the principle of effective judicial protection.
Once the case had been resumed, the Justice of the Peace dismissed the challenge by judgment no. 221 of 2025, filed on 6 October 2025. The judgment relied on the «information sheet», in which the foreign national had stated that he did not wish to apply for international protection and did not have a permit pending renewal. Yet a very different sequence had been documented in the proceedings, without being disputed: the sending of the postal kit for renewal of the permit on 4 March 2024, the summons for fingerprinting on 25 March 2024, the application for international protection made on that same day, and the issue of the provisional permit for asylum seekers and its renewal on 18 September 2025.
The decision
The Court upholds both grounds of appeal. On the first, it finds reasoning that is merely apparent and a failure to examine a decisive fact: the statement recorded in the information sheet was true when it was made, but had been overtaken by subsequent events, and the Justice of the Peace, the Court observes, is «called upon to assess the current situation, not the one captured at the moment of the arrest of the protection applicant».
On the second ground, the Court states that «The receipt of the application for international protection constitutes a provisional residence permit, which grants the applicant the right to remain in the territory of the State until the proceedings are concluded», and that the court, while acknowledging the formal correctness of the Prefect’s decree, «could not confine itself to assessing the original legitimacy of the measure, but had to verify whether the conditions for expulsion still existed at the time of the decision». It recalls the principle, restated by Cass. n. 6011 del 2024, that an application made after the expulsion does not invalidate the decree but suspends its effects, and adds that, when the provisional permit is issued, that principle means the court cannot rule on expellability by upholding the decree. The judgment is quashed and the case referred back to the Justice of the Peace of Ragusa, sitting in a different composition.
The commentary
The order does not stand alone. It is the last piece of a path that the First Civil Section has travelled in a few months and which, read as a whole, finally gives the asylum seeker facing expulsion a coherent procedural status.
By order no. 11888 of 2026, published on 30 April 2026, the Court had established that the Justice of the Peace, when presented with proof of the protection application, must stay the expulsion challenge proceedings, following the model of the improper stay under art. 295 c.p.c., until the decision of the Territorial Commission and, if that decision is challenged, until the decision of the Court (Tribunale), after assessing the fumus that may derive from the granting of interim suspension. The reason is that the subject matter of the proceedings, the Court writes, «no longer concerns, and only, the legitimacy of an administrative measure, but also the right of the foreign national to remain in the territory of the State, under the prohibition of their refoulement». By order no. 21379 of 2026, published on 23 June 2026, the Court had added that an application made after the decree suspends its enforceability and requires the court to verify, before deciding, what measure the Commission has adopted and what the outcome of any challenge is, citing Cass. n. 34155 del 2025, and that the prohibition in art. 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act has the force of a general protective rule, applicable also to expulsion ordered under art. 14, comma 5-ter. Order no. 24437 closes the circle: once the provisional permit has been issued, non-expellability is no longer a possibility to be awaited, but a bar to expulsion that already exists.
The courts of merit are moving in the same direction and show its practical consequences. The Justice of the Peace of Naples, by judgment of 29 May 2026, annulled an expulsion decree after the Court of Naples, specialised section, had granted the application for suspension made under art. 35-bis, commi 4 and 5, of d.lgs. (legislative decree) n. 25 del 2008, holding the foreign national non-expellable under art. 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act. The Court of Rome, by order of 15 October 2025, upheld by the panel on appeal (reclamo) by order of 9 March 2026, albeit with different reasoning, recognised the right to a re-entry visa, under art. 8 of d.P.R. (Presidential Decree) n. 394 del 1999, of a person who had expressed at the validation hearing the wish to apply for asylum and had been repatriated the following day; the panel recalled, citing Cass. n. 20404 del 2020, that the making of the application «occurs with the expression by the foreign national of the wish to seek protection».
The thread linking these decisions is simple, and it is worth stating clearly. The expulsion decree captures a moment; the person, however, lives in time, and the time of the proceedings is often long. Requiring the court to decide on the basis of a statement taken immediately after the person was traced, ignoring what happened afterwards and is documented in the case file, would turn a police form into a procedural bar, contrary to art. 10, third paragraph, of the Constitution and to the prohibition of refoulement. One aspect remains to be followed. The orders concern the rules prior to the European Pact on Migration and Asylum; for applications subject to the new regime, the right to remain is now based on art. 10 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, and it will be necessary to see how the principle stated by the Court fits with those rules.
What changes in practice
For those who receive an expulsion decree and have applied, or intend to apply, for protection, and for those who assist them, the guidance is precise: a) every fact subsequent to the decree must be pleaded and documented in the challenge proceedings, starting with the p.e.c. (certified e-mail) by which the wish to apply for asylum was expressed, the receipt of the application, the provisional permit and its renewals; b) if the application is pending, a stay of the proceedings must be expressly requested until the decision of the Commission and, in the event of an appeal, of the Court, producing any interim suspension decree; c) a judgment that ignores these documents can be challenged before the Court of Cassation for merely apparent reasoning and failure to examine a decisive fact, as well as for breach of art. 19 of the Consolidated Act and of art. 4 of d.lgs. n. 142 del 2015; d) if the person has been removed despite having already expressed the wish to apply for asylum, interim relief remains available to obtain a re-entry visa, as the case decided by the Court of Rome shows.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 26 October 2026
Legislative references: art. 10, third paragraph, Cost.; art. 33 of the 1951 Geneva Convention; artt. 13, 14 and 19 d.lgs. 25 luglio 1998, n. 286; art. 4 d.lgs. 18 agosto 2015, n. 142; artt. 7 and 35-bis d.lgs. 28 gennaio 2008, n. 25; art. 18 d.lgs. 1° settembre 2011, n. 150; artt. 181, 295 and 360, first paragraph, nn. 4 and 5, c.p.c.; art. 8 d.P.R. 31 agosto 1999, n. 394; art. 10 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348.
Precedents cited: Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 11888 del 2026; Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 21379 del 2026; Cass. n. 34155 del 2025; Cass. ord. n. 16439 del 2025; Cass. n. 6011 del 2024; Cass. n. 20404 del 2020; Justice of the Peace of Naples, judgment of 29 May 2026; Court of Rome, order of 15 October 2025, R.G. n. 34189/2025, and panel order of 9 March 2026, R.G. n. 49946/2025.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.