The ruling
Court of Cassation (Corte di cassazione), First Civil Section, order no. 22869 of 2026, decided in chambers on 5 June 2026 and published on 7 July 2026, General Register (R.G.) no. 23737/2025. President ACIERNO, reporting judge CAIAZZO
“[...] no automatic bar to the grant of that renewal applies and there is no absolute presumption of the applicant’s social dangerousness, which must instead be established in concrete terms and as at the present time, in application of the general and systemic principle, deriving also from EU law, according to which, in immigration law, where fundamental human rights of constitutional importance are exercised, a reasonable and proportionate balancing of the interests involved is required [...]”
Principle stated by Cass. n. 23597 del 2023 and n. 19672 del 2025 on the renewal of residence permits on humanitarian grounds, recalled by the Court and applied to proceedings challenging expulsion.
The case
The Prefect of Bari had expelled a foreign national in January 2024, grounding social dangerousness on a drug-related conviction. The Justice of the Peace (giudice di pace) of Bari, by decision no. 1049 of 2025, published on 22 July 2025, had dismissed the challenge.
The appeal to the Court of Cassation raised two grounds. The first concerned the very legitimacy of the decree: it had emerged from the administration’s pleadings that the applicant, released from prison on 22 November 2023, had been held without interruption first in the pre-removal detention centre (C.P.R.) of Trapani-Milo and then in that of Bari-Palese, in execution of a judicial expulsion ordered in 2018 by the supervisory court (magistratura di sorveglianza) of Verona, so that the Prefect could not have adopted a new decree. The second alleged merely apparent reasoning on dangerousness and failure to examine the documents produced: commendations, educational qualifications, training certificates, reports on the prison treatment programme, and decisions granting reward leave (permessi premio).
The decision
The Court examines the second ground first, because it is logically preliminary, upholds it and declares the other absorbed. The Justice of the Peace, the order reads, «did not give reasons on the applicant’s dangerousness, presuming it on the basis of the previous drug offence, without carrying out a current and concrete assessment, and without taking into account the rehabilitation path undertaken by the applicant, including during the execution of the custodial sentence imposed». The judgment is quashed and the case referred back to the Justice of the Peace of Bari, in a different composition.
The most interesting point is the principle recalled. It originated in the context of the renewal of residence permits on humanitarian grounds, under the regime prior to d.l. (decree-law) n. 113 del 2018, and the Court bases it on a criterion it describes as general and systemic, deriving also from EU law, drawing on the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 27 September 2022 and on Constitutional Court judgment no. 88 of 2023. Applying it to expulsion means recognising that this is not a sector-specific rule, but a canon governing the whole of immigration law.
The commentary
The decisions of 2026 confirm this reading. By order no. 5164 of 2026, published on 6 March 2026, the Court quashed a decree of the Court of Milan that had refused special protection by emphasising the seriousness of the offence committed and overlooking the subsequent conduct, and recalled, citing Cass. n. 22807 del 2022, that «whenever the legislature provides that a socially dangerous foreign national may not enter, stay or remain in the national territory, the existence of the requirement of dangerousness must be established in concrete terms and as at the present time, even where the provision identifies specific conduct, or previous convictions, that the legislature has deemed indicative for the purposes of the assessment of dangerousness»; in that case seventeen years had passed without offences, probation under the supervision of social services (affidamento in prova) had been successfully completed and the employment relationship had become permanent. By order no. 10022 of 2026, published on 18 April 2026, it censured a Justice of the Peace who had merely referred to criminal and police records, which were moreover contradicted by the criminal record certificate, and had not assessed family ties, recalling, citing Cass. n. 26173 del 2023, that dangerousness must be assessed in concrete terms and as at the present time, «since the court cannot confine itself to referring to the criminal records cited in the expulsion decree or in another judicial measure, from which no external res judicata effect or bar to the exercise of the assessment it is called upon to carry out derives». By order no. 21379 of 2026 it ruled out that the assessment of dangerousness may be inferred from a mere committal for trial, without saying anything about the nature of the offence charged.
The courts of merit offer telling examples. The Justice of the Peace of Prato, by judgment of 17 March 2026, annulled a decree of 15 January 2026 based on a conviction for very serious offences because, in the face of more than a decade of subsequent conduct, semi-liberty, work, voluntary activity, the reports of the U.E.P.E. (the probation service) and family ties in Italy, the administration had said nothing about the current nature of the dangerousness, and concluded that it could in no way find that a concrete and current dangerousness existed. The Court of Rome, by decree of 28 March 2025, declared unlawful the revocation of subsidiary protection based solely on the conviction, holding that revocation on grounds of dangerousness must be based «on an individualised and current assessment of the risk to public order and security».
There is, in this case law, a coherence that goes beyond technique. Art. 27, third paragraph, of the Constitution requires punishment to aim at rehabilitation; the State invests in prison treatment, grants reward leave, semi-liberty and early release, and certifies the results. It would be contradictory if, when deciding on removal, the same administration ignored what its own offices had established, as if the person had stood still since the day of the offence. Dangerousness is not a permanent quality but an assessment of the present; and, when private and family life protected by art. 8 of the European Convention depends on the expulsion, that assessment must be balanced against the person’s roots in the country.
What changes in practice
In proceedings challenging expulsion, and even before that in submissions to the administration, it is advisable: a) to produce complete documentation of the path taken during and after the sentence, that is, summary reports and U.E.P.E. reports, decisions of the supervisory court, training certificates, employment contracts, payslips and Unilav notifications, together with up-to-date criminal record and pending charges certificates; b) to challenge decrees and judgments that merely list previous convictions, asking for dangerousness to be established in concrete terms and as at the present time; c) to plead specifically family ties and the length of stay, which the court must assess under artt. 13, comma 2-bis, and 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act; d) to indicate precisely, also in the appeal to the Court of Cassation, where in the case file the unexamined documents are to be found, as the Court emphasised in order no. 5164 of 2026.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 26 October 2026
Legislative references: art. 27, third paragraph, Cost.; art. 8 ECHR; artt. 4, comma 3, 13, commi 2 and 2-bis, 16 and 19, comma 1.1, d.lgs. 25 luglio 1998, n. 286; art. 18 d.lgs. 1° settembre 2011, n. 150; art. 132, second paragraph, n. 4, and art. 360, first paragraph, n. 5, c.p.c.
Precedents cited: Cass. n. 23597 del 2023 and n. 19672 del 2025, cited in the order; ECtHR, 27 September 2022; Corte cost., sent. n. 88 del 2023; Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 5164 del 2026; Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 10022 del 2026; Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 21379 del 2026; Cass. n. 22807 del 2022; Cass. n. 26173 del 2023; Justice of the Peace of Prato, judgment of 17 March 2026; Court of Rome, decree of 28 March 2025, R.G. n. 36154/2023.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.