The rulings
Court of Rome, Section for personal rights and immigration, judgment of 29 September 2026, General Register (R.G.) no. 24772/2026, and judgment no. 14179 published on 13 October 2026, R.G. no. 25435/2026, delivered on applications brought under the simplified procedure pursuant to art. 281-decies c.p.c. (Code of Civil Procedure)
The case
Two Peruvian nationals wanted to apply for international protection in Rome. Several times, in the spring of 2026, they tried to gain access to the Immigration Office of the Police Headquarters (Questura): long waits outside the offices, even at night, no possibility of booking, refusals given orally. In mid-April, through their lawyer, they expressed in writing, by p.e.c., their wish to apply for asylum. The Questura replied that appointments were reserved for vulnerabilities certified by a hospital or by a doctor of the local health authority (ASL), and invited them to present themselves in person at the counters.
Time, meanwhile, went by, and on 12 June 2026 Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, the new Asylum Procedure Regulation of the European Pact on Migration and Asylum, became applicable, with rules that are stricter on many points. Art. 79, paragraph 3, of the Regulation makes it applicable to applications lodged from 12 June 2026, leaving those lodged earlier to Directive 2013/32/EU; art. 17, comma 4, of d.l. (decree-law) 12 giugno 2026, n. 100, converted by Law of 7 August 2026, no. 145, keeps the previous rules for proceedings initiated following the making of the application on an earlier date.
Had the two applicants’ application been made in April, when they expressed it, or in June or later, whenever the Questura might decide to formally lodge it?
The decision
The Court answered in the first sense. Expressing the wish to seek protection requires no particular form, as provided by art. 2 of d.lgs. (legislative decree) n. 142 del 2015 and as recalled by recital 27 of the Regulation, and may take place by any suitable act, including a p.e.c. addressed to the administration (Cass. civ., n. 24138 del 2024, cited in the second judgment); in the second case it had been sent by the lawyer holding a special power of attorney. It is from that moment that the person acquires the status of applicant. The Regulation distinguishes between making, registering and lodging an application, but the second and third are tasks of the administration, which cannot decide after the event which law applies.
The two judgments ordered the Ministry of the Interior to formally lodge the applications, the first with the issue of the residence permit provided for by art. 4 of d.lgs. n. 142 del 2015, the second within seven days; and the second expressly declared that the application made on 15 April 2026 remains subject to Directive 2013/32/EU. The second judgment also recalls the European rule under which States may not require unnecessary or disproportionate documents or impose other administrative requirements on those seeking protection (art. 6, paragraph 2, of Directive (EU) 2024/1346), and classifies as an unlawful practice the conduct of the Questura, which neither registered nor lodged the application and did not set any appointment.
The commentary
The decisions reaffirm a principle that ought to be obvious: the right of asylum, guaranteed by art. 10, third paragraph, of the Constitution and by art. 18 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the Union, cannot depend on the availability of a counter and on the workload of those who staff it. If it were the date of lodging that decided the applicable regime, the length of the queue at the Questura and the decision whether or not to grant an appointment would become a variable of substantive law, and two people who fled the same country on the same day could be treated differently simply because one found a place and the other did not. That is the opposite of legal certainty and equal treatment.
The most delicate point, which the commentators themselves highlight, is the reading of art. 17, comma 4, of d.l. n. 100 del 2026: it could be argued that the transitional provision refers only to proceedings already formally initiated.
But the second judgment rightly observes that the legislature wrote «making» (presentazione), not «lodging» (formalizzazione), and that the two words have distinct meanings in the new European system. Between two possible readings, preference must be given to the one that does not make the foreign national bear the inefficiency of the administration, in line with the maxim nemo auditur propriam turpitudinem allegans, which applies to the State as well.
The underlying problem remains, and no judgment can solve it on its own: access to the asylum procedure is the first of the applicant’s rights, and a Questura that does not receive applications, in Rome as elsewhere, denies that right before anyone has even examined it. The exercise of a right cannot be tied to the goodwill of those who are supposed to receive the expression of will; it must have certain rules, always and everywhere.
What changes in practice
A foreign national who wishes to apply for international protection and cannot get the competent offices to receive them must leave a written record of their request, with a certain date: a p.e.c. sent by a lawyer, a written request handed in and registered, the statement of a support worker. From that day the person is an asylum seeker, cannot be expelled to the country from which they fled, and their application follows the rules in force at that time. No one should give up a right out of exhaustion simply because the staff who should receive the application are not willing, for a thousand reasons, to do so, so much so that the court can order the Questura to receive the application.
If difficulties arise in the protection procedure, it is necessary to turn to a lawyer experienced in immigration law. The judgments indicate the remedy, an application to the court under the simplified procedure against the Ministry of the Interior, the only proper defendant, and the evidence to be offered: documented attempts at access, a p.e.c. with a special power of attorney, the office’s replies. In proceedings in which the administration applies Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 to applications expressed before 12 June 2026, the date on which the wish was expressed must always be pleaded and proved, and the issue must be raised before the Territorial Commission and the specialised section. On the interpretation of art. 17, comma 4, the case law is not yet settled, and a preliminary reference to the Court of Justice on art. 79 of the Regulation cannot be ruled out.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 26 October 2026
Legislative references: art. 10, third paragraph, Cost.; art. 18 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union; artt. 3, 26, 27, 28 and 79 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348; Directive 2013/32/EU; art. 6, paragraph 2, of Directive (EU) 2024/1346; artt. 2 and 4 d.lgs. 18 agosto 2015, n. 142; art. 17, commi 1, 2 and 4, d.l. 12 giugno 2026, n. 100, converted by l. 7 agosto 2026, n. 145; art. 281-decies c.p.c.
Precedents cited: Cass. civ., sez. un., ord. n. 5059 del 2017; Cass. civ., n. 24138 del 2024; CJEU, Case C-429/15, Danqua, all cited in the judgments.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.