Studio Legale Mariani
EN
Contact

Commentary · Immigration case lawImmigration · Complementary protection and integration · From the firm's archive

Stable employment is rootedness: the Court of Cassation and the protection of those who have built a life in Italy

By order no. 15667 of 2023, obtained by the firm, the Court of Cassation set aside the refusal of complementary protection to a worker in stable employment: social and occupational integration was of direct relevance. The rules changed in 2023, but the protection of private and family life remains.

Avv. Giuseppe MARIANIPublished on 9 November 2026Reading time: 8 minutes

The ruling

Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 15667 of 2023, decided in chambers on 5 April 2023, published on 5 June 2023, R.G. n. 9720/2022. President ACIERNO, judge rapporteur AMATORE

“The burden of allegation focuses on the situation of rootedness and integration achieved in our country”

The passage concerns art. 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act on Immigration as introduced by d.l. n. 130 del 2020, applicable to the case. From the firm's collection of orders upholding appeals: appeal argued by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI.

SentenzeWeb database of the Court of Cassation

The case

A national of a South Asian country, belonging to a religious minority, applies for international protection, recounting attacks and threats suffered in his homeland. The Territorial Commission rejects the application. The Court of Potenza, by decree of 28 February 2022, confirms the refusal: it finds his account not credible, rules out a generalised armed conflict and also refuses complementary protection, observing that the applicant had produced «only employment-related documentation» showing that he was in stable employment, and that integration, in itself, was not enough.

The appeal to the Court of Cassation argued by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI challenges the merely apparent reasoning of the decree, the failure to examine the situation in the country and, above all, the error regarding complementary protection.

The decision

The First Section dismisses the first two grounds but upholds the third. It reconstructs art. 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act in the wording of d.l. n. 130 del 2020, applicable to the application, and recalls that complementary protection, like the humanitarian protection it replaces, is a fundamental right of the person, which contributes to implementing the constitutional right of asylum. The second part of the provision gave «direct relevance» to social and family integration in Italy, to be assessed taking into account family ties, social integration, the length of stay and ties with the country of origin.

The latter, the Court specifies, are an element of assessment, not a constitutive fact of the right: the applicant does not have to prove that he has severed all ties with his country; the burden of allegation focuses on the rootedness achieved in Italy, while the situation in the country of origin falls within the court's investigative powers. The Court of Potenza had not adequately assessed the appellant's social and occupational integration. The decree is set aside and the case referred back to the Court of Potenza, differently composed.

The commentary

A man arrives in Italy, applies for protection, finds a job and keeps it. For the court of merit those payslips were not an argument; they were almost evidence to the contrary. The Court of Cassation reversed the perspective: stable employment is the most concrete form of rootedness, and removing someone who has built it means striking at his private life, that is, at a fundamental right. The person comes before the legal category into which one might wish to fit him.

There is also a lesson of method, which remains valuable. Requiring a person seeking protection to provide negative proof that he no longer has ties in his homeland means asking the impossible. The Court clearly distinguishes what is for the applicant, to recount and document the life built here, from what is for the court, to establish the situation in the country of origin using its own investigative powers. It is the same idea of cooperation in fact-finding that underpins the whole law of international protection.

The legislative framework, however, changed after the ruling. D.l. 10 marzo 2023, n. 20, converted by law 5 maggio 2023, n. 50, in force from 11 March 2023, repealed the third and fourth sentences of art. 19, comma 1.1, that is, precisely the part on private and family life and on the integration criteria; for applications submitted up to that date, or where the foreign national had already received from the Questura the invitation to submit one, the previous rules continue to apply. The reference to constitutional and international obligations in art. 5, comma 6, remains in force, and the Court of Cassation has drawn the consequence: even under the new regime, refusal of entry and expulsion in breach of those obligations are not permitted, because private and family life is the subject of an individual right protected by art. 8 of the European Convention (Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 26522 del 2026, citing Cass. n. 29593 del 2025). The protection of rootedness, therefore, has not disappeared: its legal basis has changed.

What changes in practice

Those who have lived and worked in Italy for some time, and are at risk of losing their permit or being removed, should know that their rootedness still counts: employment contracts, payslips, social security contributions, housing, language courses, family and personal ties are evidence of a life that the law protects. It is advisable to gather them carefully and hand them to the lawyer in good time. Applications submitted before 11 March 2023 are still governed by the 2020 rules.

Defence counsel's role is first of all one of classification: the date of the application must be checked to identify the applicable regime and, under the post-2023 regime, the request must be based on art. 5, comma 6, and on art. 8 of the European Convention, documenting sufficiently strong rootedness. The 2023 ruling retains its value as regards the allocation of burdens: the applicant must allege the integration achieved, not prove that he has severed his ties with his country of origin, while the court must activate its own investigative powers.

Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI

Potenza, 9 November 2026

Legislative references: arts. 2, 10, third paragraph, and 117, first paragraph, Cost.; art. 8 ECHR; arts. 5, comma 6, and 19, commi 1.1 and 1.2, d.lgs. 25 luglio 1998, n. 286; d.l. 21 ottobre 2020, n. 130, converted by l. 18 dicembre 2020, n. 173; art. 7, commi 1, lett. c), and 2, d.l. 10 marzo 2023, n. 20, converted by l. 5 maggio 2023, n. 50; art. 14, lett. c), d.lgs. 19 novembre 2007, n. 251.

Precedents cited: Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 15667 del 2023; Cass., Sez. U., n. 24413 del 2021; Cass. n. 18455 del 2022 and n. 36789 del 2022; Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 26522 del 2026; Cass. n. 29593 del 2025.

The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.

← Back to Immigration case law