Introduction
The third issue covers the week from 2 to 9 November 2026 and collects the rulings made known in that period that were not already in the previous issues, together with a referral order published on 28 October and not reported in issue no. 2. The firm's historical archive continues with an order of the Court of Cassation upholding an appeal on complementary protection, accompanied by a signed commentary and an indication of the provisions in force today, which changed after the ruling.
Each case note is drafted after reading the text of the decision, except where expressly stated; the parties are never named, and personal data are omitted even when the decision contains them.
In brief
The common thread of this issue is the relationship between safeguards and proof. The Court of Cassation reaffirms that a person who has expressed the intention to apply for asylum is an applicant, and that it is for the administration to prove a withdrawal; but it also specifies that, once the application has been rejected as manifestly unfounded without suspension, the mere pendency of the proceedings does not halt enforcement. The Court of Bologna denies the effects of a border procedure initiated on statistical data alone; the Ministry of Defence competition reopens to foreign nationals in compliance with a judgment of the Court of Milan; the Court of Avellino brings before the Constitutional Court and the Court of Justice the provision that treats the citizenship of minors born abroad as never acquired. From the firm's archive, an order of 2023 recalls that stable employment is rootedness. On detention, the question of the directive of 3 November 2026 on fitness examinations remains open, as discussed in theLegal Watch.
Supreme courts: the latest rulings
Expression of intention and implicit withdrawal. Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 28221 del 2026
References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 28221, decided in chambers on 7 October 2026, published on 2 November 2026, R.G. n. 20775/2026, President Acierno, judge rapporteur Scalia.
The facts. On 29 April 2026 a foreign national expresses at the Questura the intention to apply for protection; the application is not formalised. On 5 September he is expelled and detained in the C.P.R.: the decree treats the application as implicitly abandoned because he failed to attend an appointment. The justice of the peace validates the detention, postponing the examination of the application to a later stage.
The principle. The Court sets aside the decision and, ruling on the merits, refuses validation. The status of applicant arises with the expression of intention, including for expressions made before 12 June 2026, and in a manner compatible with d.l. n. 100 del 2026. The validation judge cannot merely take note that the application was not formalised: the judge must verify whether the status has lapsed, and it is for the administration to prove that the person was actually summoned and was aware of the consequences of failing to appear. Lawfulness is assessed «now as at that time»: the subsequent rejection of the application by the Commission does not cure the validation.
Practical implications. The expression of intention must always be documented and proof of the summons requested at the hearing: in its absence, implicit withdrawal cannot be presumed.
Manifest unfoundedness and alternative measures. Cass. civ., sez. I, ord. n. 28337 del 2026
References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 28337, decided in chambers on 7 October 2026, published on 3 November 2026, R.G. n. 20242/2026, President Acierno, judge rapporteur Scalia; appeal by the Ministry of the Interior.
The facts. A foreign national's application for protection had been rejected as manifestly unfounded under the accelerated procedure and the Court had dismissed the application for suspension. The Questore orders the measures alternative to detention under art. 14, comma 1-bis, of the Consolidated Act; the justice of the peace refuses validation, holding that the pendency of the protection proceedings conferred the right to remain.
The principle. The Court sets aside the decision and refers the case back. In cases of rejection as manifestly unfounded, the appeal does not suspend the effects of the refusal, under art. 35-bis, comma 3, lett. c), of d.lgs. n. 25 del 2008: the mere pendency of the proceedings does not preclude enforcement of the expulsion nor does it, by itself, justify refusing validation, unless a suspension order has been made. The respondent's objections concerning the rights of the defence and the lack of translation are declared inadmissible, because they should have been raised by a conditional cross-appeal.
Practical implications. The court to which the case is referred back will have to assess the current state of the protection proceedings: every favourable interim decision must be produced. In proceedings before the Court of Cassation, defences challenging unfavourable rulings, including implicit ones, must be raised by a cross-appeal.
Supreme courts: from the firm's historical archive
Stable employment is rootedness: complementary protection and integration
References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 15667 of 2023, decided in chambers on 5 April 2023, published on 5 June 2023, R.G. n. 9720/2022. President ACIERNO, judge rapporteur AMATORE; registered in the official database SentenzeWeb.
The facts. An asylum applicant, belonging to a religious minority, is refused any form of protection by the Court of Potenza; as to complementary protection, the decree observes that he had produced «only employment-related documentation», showing stable employment, and that integration was not enough.
The principle. The First Section upholds the ground of appeal on complementary protection. Under the text of art. 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act introduced by d.l. n. 130 del 2020, social and family integration has «direct relevance»; ties with the country of origin are an element of assessment, not a constitutive fact, so the applicant does not have to prove that he has severed them, while the situation in the country falls within the court's investigative powers. The Court had not adequately assessed his social and occupational integration: the decree is set aside and the case referred back.
Practical implications. The framework has changed: d.l. n. 20 del 2023, in force from 11 March 2023, repealed the third and fourth sentences of art. 19, comma 1.1, except for applications submitted up to that date; the Court of Cassation has, however, clarified that protection of private and family life remains, on the basis of art. 5, comma 6, and of art. 8 of the European Convention (Cass., sez. I, ord. n. 26522 del 2026, citing Cass. n. 29593 del 2025).
The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →
Questions before the Constitutional Court
Citizenship of minors born abroad. Court of Avellino, order of 18 September 2026
References. Court of Avellino, order of 18 September 2026, entered as no. 176 in the 2026 register of referral orders, published in the Official Gazette, 1st special series, no. 43 of 28 October 2026; question of constitutionality and preliminary reference to the Court of Justice.
The facts. Four minors, born abroad between 2010 and 2025 and holding another citizenship, are the children of persons whose status as Italian citizens by descent has been established by a final judgment. The request to register their birth certificates, submitted after 27 March 2025, is refused by the civil registrar under art. 3-bis of law n. 91 del 1992, introduced by d.l. n. 36 del 2025.
The principle. The Court considers the provision directly applicable and not open to a conforming interpretation. It raises a question of constitutionality on grounds of reasonableness, protection of legitimate expectations and protection of status civitatis, and asks the Court of Justice whether arts. 9 TEU and 20 TFEU, read in the light of arts. 7 and 24 of the Charter, preclude a provision that treats as never acquired a citizenship arising ipso iure at birth, without an individual examination of the consequences for citizenship of the Union and without assessing the best interests of the child.
Practical implications. In similar proceedings it is advisable to request a stay pending the decisions or to raise the same questions independently, documenting the date of the application and the situation of the minors.
Case law of the courts of merit
Border procedure based on statistical data alone. Court of Bologna, decree of 1 October 2026
References. Court of Bologna, specialised section for immigration and international protection, decree of 1 October 2026, R.G. n. 15588/2026. Text read in the PDF published by Melting Pot, whose extraction is partly incomplete, and in the accompanying article.
The facts. An asylum applicant, who landed in Sardinia and was transferred to a centre for the border procedure in Emilia, has his application rejected as manifestly unfounded under the accelerated procedure, initiated by the President of the Commission on the basis of the recognition rate of 20 per cent or less for his country.
The principle. The Court converts the procedure from art. 35-ter to art. 35-bis of d.lgs. n. 25 del 2008 and declares the right to remain on the territory for the duration of the proceedings. The statistical data under art. 42, par. 1, lett. j), of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 have only indicative value and do not replace the individual assessment: the determination and the decision had to explain why the applicant's personal circumstances did not make the percentage unrepresentative. Without that assessment the accelerated procedure is not validly initiated and does not produce its derogating effects, including the exclusion of automatic suspension; the Court cites Cass., Sez. U., n. 11399 del 2024.
Practical implications. In appeals against decisions taken at the border, the reasons for initiating the procedure must always be challenged, seeking a declaration of the automatic suspensive effect.
Public competitions and citizenship. Court of Milan, judgment no. 5127 of 2026
References. Court of Milan, employment section, judgment no. 5127 of 29 October 2026, as indicated in the notice of the Ministry of Defence published on the inPA portal on 5 November 2026. The text of the judgment is not yet available: the case note reports only what appears from the official act of the Ministry.
The facts. The call for applications for 1,100 assistants at the Ministry of Defence, for administrative and technical profiles, required Italian citizenship.
The principle. In compliance with the operative part of the judgment, the Ministry partially amended the call and reopened the time limits: citizens of the Union and of third countries holding the residence documents indicated in art. 38, commi 1 and 3-bis, of d.lgs. n. 165 del 2001 may apply. The Ministry states that compliance does not amount to acquiescence in the decision.
Practical implications. Those who meet the requirements should apply within the reopened time limit, checking it in the competition area of the inPA portal. The case note will be completed when the text of the judgment becomes available.
Administrative courts
The week's check. In the sources consulted for this issue there are no rulings of the administrative courts on immigration to report from 2 to 9 November 2026.
European Courts
The week's check. None of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights published on HUDOC from 2 to 5 November 2026 concerns Italy. On removal: in its judgment of 5 November 2026, A.M. v. Bulgaria, application no. 23441/25, the Court found that expulsion to Uzbekistan would violate art. 3 of the Convention; in its judgment of 3 November 2026, A.H. v. Serbia and North Macedonia, applications nos. 60417/16 and 79749/16, it found violations of art. 3, in its procedural limb and in relation to expulsion, by both States. The data are taken from HUDOC; the full text of the judgments has not been extracted. Press releases nos. 154 to 161 of 2026 of the Court of Justice do not concern immigration or asylum.
Practical implications. The two judgments confirm that the risk of ill-treatment in the country of destination must be assessed in concrete terms before removal, with an effective examination of the allegations.
From the reviews of the Court of Cassation
On 23 October 2026 the Massimario Office, in cooperation with the European Union Agency for Asylum, published the thematic review «Persecution for political opinion and sur placeprotection», of 47 pages, which collects the case law of the Court of Cassation and of the European courts on the subject, presented at the conference of 27 October. On 2 November the monthly review of civil case law for July 2026 was published.
Notes
The case notes are for information purposes only and do not constitute legal advice on a specific case. Decisions of the courts of merit are rulings on individual cases, often interim, and do not have the force of binding precedents.
The review is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.
← Back to Immigration case law