Introduction
The second issue covers the week from 26 October to 2 November 2026 and collects the rulings made known during the period that were not already in issue 1. In addition, the latest rulings of the Court of Cassation on the application for protection and on detention, not reported in issue 1, have been searched for on SentenzeWeb. Finally, the firm's historical archive is opened, with two orders of the Court of Cassation upholding appeals, obtained in proceedings argued by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI, each accompanied by a signed commentary. The archive will continue in the coming issues, with the caveat that those rulings must be read in the light of the rules in force today.
Each case note is drafted after reading the full text of the decision; the parties are never named, and personal data are omitted even where the decision contains them.
In brief
The common thread of this issue is the inaction of the offices. The Court of Cassation consolidates the principle that an application for protection takes effect from the expression of the wish to apply, including by p.e.c. (certified e-mail), and must be received even at the hearing to validate an escort to the border. The Court of Rome orders the Questura (Police Headquarters) to receive the permit request of a victim of exploitation, and the consulate to issue a visa to a minor who has been waiting for over thirteen months. The Court of Milan orders the Questura to receive the asylum application of a person detained in the pre-removal detention centre (C.P.R.) and opens to foreign nationals who meet the legal requirements the Revenue Agency's competition reserved for protected categories. The Court of Salerno allows an application for suspension to be renewed on the basis of new facts. From the firm's archive, two orders of the Court of Cassation recall that an asylum application arises with the expression of the wish to apply and that validation of detention requires rigorous scrutiny of the alternatives.
Supreme courts: the latest rulings
The p.e.c. and the status of applicant. Cass. civ., sez. I, ordd. nn. 25359, 25360 e 25365 del 2026
References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, orders no. 25359 (R.G. no. 19282/2026), no. 25360 (R.G. no. 19297/2026) and no. 25365, published on 15 September 2026, President Acierno, Judge Rapporteur Ruggiero; to the same effect, order no. 24296 of 31 July 2026, R.G. no. 15665/2026, President Acierno, Judge Rapporteur Reggiani.
The facts. The Justice of the Peace of Rome had validated detentions ordered on 28 July 2026, holding that the p.e.c. sent proved a mere expression of will and not the making of an application.
The principle. The Court quashes and, deciding on the merits, does not validate: the application need not already be formalised or registered, and the solution is also compatible with d.l. n. 100 del 2026. In no. 24296 the Court recalls that the Administration has the duty to receive a request sent by p.e.c., refraining from any measure that would prevent its examination.
Practical implications. The p.e.c. with its receipts must always be produced before the validation judge: the lack of a reply from the Questura cannot be borne by the foreign national.
The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →
Application at the hearing to validate an escort. Cass. civ., sez. I, sentt. nn. 13625 e 15549 del 2026
References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, judgment no. 13625, published on 11 May 2026, R.G. no. 17465/2024, President and Judge Rapporteur Acierno; judgment no. 15549, published on 21 May 2026, R.G. no. 13095/2024, President Acierno, Judge Rapporteur Reggiani.
The facts. In both cases the application for protection had been made at the hearing to validate the forced escort to the border ordered by the Questore.
The principle. No. 15549 states that the application «must be received by the Justice of the Peace, after being recorded in the minutes, and promptly forwarded to the competent authority». No. 13625 requires the court to verify whether the exhaustive exceptions in art. 7, comma 2, of d.lgs. n. 25 del 2008 apply, provided that the application is not utterly generic; in other cases the removal cannot be validated, because the applicant has the right to remain in the territory of the State.
Practical implications. The application must be recorded in the minutes with an indication, even a summary one, of the reasons. The court's power to assess its genericness is under debate in legal scholarship.
The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →
Supreme courts: from the firm's historical archive
A p.e.c. to the Questura is enough: a person who has asked for asylum is an applicant even if no one has yet received them
References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 29557 of 2025, decided in chambers on 25 September 2025, published on 7 November 2025, R.G. no. 24478/2024. President ACIERNO, reporting judge IOFRIDA; recorded in the official database SentenzeWeb.
The facts. A foreign national, still at liberty, sends a p.e.c. to the Questura on 10 October 2024 to request the appointment needed to formalise an application for international protection. No one replies. On 21 October he is served with the expulsion decree and the order for detention in the C.P.R. of Palazzo San Gervasio; the Justice of the Peace of Melfi validates it, holding that, since the time limits for the summons had not expired, he could not yet be considered an applicant, and rejects the objection of lack of competence.
The principle. The First Section upholds the appeal and quashes without referral. Citing orders no. 21910 of 2020 and no. 9597 of 2024, it recalls that the «protective status» arises «at the moment of the actual expression of will of the asylum seeker»: the directive distinguishes between the making of the application and its registration by the authority, and the duty to receive the application is the necessary corollary of that expression. Competence for validating the detention of an applicant lies with the specialised section of the Court (Tribunale) and not with the Justice of the Peace. In the case at hand the detention «was null and could not be validated», and since the mandatory time limit for validation had expired the Court decided without referral.
Practical implications. The principle remains relevant, but the rules on competence and procedures have changed: the facts must be checked against the regime in force at the time.
The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →
A pre-printed formula is not enough to take away liberty: the validation judge must look at the alternatives to the C.P.R.
References. Court of Cassation, First Civil Section, order no. 13113 of 2023, decided in chambers on 17 April 2023, published on 12 May 2023, R.G. no. 5608/2022. President DE CHIARA, reporting judge SCOTTI; recorded in the official database SentenzeWeb.
The facts. In January 2022 a foreign national is detained in the C.P.R. of Palazzo San Gervasio. At the hearing his lawyer objects, arguing that the conditions of artt. 13 and 14 of the Consolidated Act were not met and that non-coercive measures should have been applied. The Justice of the Peace of Melfi validates by a measure which merely indicates the need to obtain the documents and to wait for the carriers and holds the conditions to be met. The appeal complains that this was a ready-made printed form, devoid of reasoning.
The principle. The First Section upholds the appeal. The person concerned had stated, without challenge, that he had a valid passport, a necessary condition for the alternative measures of art. 14, comma 1-bis. On the basis of order no. 7829 of 2019 and of the judgment of the Court of Justice of 5 June 2014, Case C-146/14, Mahdi, the Court recalls that the judge must carry out an assessment of proportionality and evaluate whether a less coercive measure can be applied. Detention is permissible only if there is a risk of absconding or if the foreign national avoids or hampers the preparation of return. The Justice of the Peace «disregarded that aspect»: the decree was quashed without referral, since the time limit for validation had expired.
Practical implications. Directive 2008/115/EC will be repealed with effect from 17 October 2027 by Regulation (EU) 2026/2280: after that date the proportionality argument will have to be reconsidered in the light of the new text.
The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →
Case law of the courts of merit
Asylum application in the C.P.R. and urgent application. Court of Milan, order of 27 October 2026
References. Court of Milan, Specialised Section for immigration, international protection and free movement of European Union citizens, order of 27 October 2026, R.G. no. 40469/2026, ex art. 700 c.p.c. Text read in the Banca Dati di Merito (case-law database of the courts of merit) of the Ministry of Justice.
The facts. A man detained in the C.P.R. of via Corelli, after validation by the Justice of the Peace on 29 August 2026, had asked several times to make an application for protection. On 14 September his lawyer had written to the centre and, by p.e.c., to the Questura; on 15 September he had sent a handwritten statement by the person concerned. No reply came. The Ministry relied on the information sheets, in which protection was not mentioned, and on an appointment which it said had already been scheduled.
The principle. The Court affirms its jurisdiction and orders the Questura to proceed with the receipt and formalisation of the application, setting the summons within the statutory time limits. The information sheets do not rule out the wish to ask for protection: they are pre-printed forms that do not indicate that option, filled in by a third party. Following Cass. n. 21910 del 2020, it holds the lawyer's p.e.c. to be in due form and finds that the registration time limits of art. 27 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 have long expired and that the appointment has not been proved. The periculum lies in the infringement of the right under art. 10, third paragraph, Cost., made more urgent by the validation of the detention. The costs are offset.
Practical implications. An urgent application is also available to those in detention: it is advisable to document every attempt by p.e.c. and by a statement signed by the person concerned. The network Mai più lager, NO ai CPR reports that a few days later the same person was taken to Malpensa for return and brought back at the last minute: this news does not appear from judicial documents, but it is a reason to send the order at once to the Questura and the centre and to leave a copy with the detained person.
The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →
Public competitions and citizenship. Court of Milan, judgment no. 4273 of 2026
References. Court of Milan, Labour Section, judgment no. 4273, published on 22 September 2026, R.G. no. 7771/2026, in the action brought by four organisations against the Revenue Agency. Applications were reopened on the inPA portal on 20 October 2026.
The facts. The call of 15 May 2026 for 622 assistants, reserved for persons entered on the lists of legge n. 68 del 1999, required Italian citizenship.
The principle. The Court affirms the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts and, on the basis of art. 45 TFEU and of art. 38, commi 1 and 3-bis, of d.lgs. n. 165 del 2001, rules out the reservation for administrative and support duties, disapplies art. 1 of d.P.C.M. n. 174 del 1994 and recognises a double discrimination, on grounds of nationality and of disability, ordering the call to be amended with a new time limit and a coercive measure.
Practical implications. Applications must be submitted by 23:59 on 19 November 2026. The action under art. 44 of the Consolidated Act can be used for other calls: the content of the duties must be examined, not only the administration.
The commentary by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI →
Victims of exploitation and the permit under art. 18-ter. Court of Rome, measure of 20 October 2026
References. Court of Rome, Section XVIII (Civil), interim measure of 20 October 2026, R.G. no. 25829/2026, ex art. 700 c.p.c.
The facts. A foreign worker, who had reported being a victim of labour exploitation and was enrolled in an emersion programme in a protected facility, had asked the Questura to formalise his request for a special cases permit. The Questura had replied that it saw no grounds, pending the opinion of the Public Prosecutor's Office.
The principle. The Court affirms the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts and makes clear that it is deciding only on the possibility of formalising the request: the Questura is the competent authority and must issue the receipt under art. 18-ter, comma 6, which allows the person to stay and work. The harm also lies in the fact that the absence of an express measure prevents any judicial review. The Questura must schedule the appointment within forty days.
Practical implications. The silence of the office does not block protection: if the request is not received, an urgent application is available, documenting the complaint and participation in the programme.
Family reunification and consular delays. Court of Rome, decree of 15 October 2026
References. Court of Rome, Section XVIII (Civil), interim decree of 15 October 2026, issued without prior summons of the other party; written hearing set for 18 November 2026.
The facts. A woman refugee had obtained clearance (nulla osta) for family reunification with a minor relative (nipote) entrusted to her under kafala. The minor, registered on the portal of the consular service provider, had been waiting for over thirteen months for an appointment declared indefinite by the consular authority, living precariously in a third country.
The principle. The Court finds the right to be fully plausible, given the status of refugee with the exemption under art. 29-bis of the Consolidated Act, the validity of the clearance and the family tie, and orders the visa to be issued with priority scheduling of the appointment within fifteen days, citing art. 3 of the New York Convention and the risk linked to the minor's approaching majority.
Practical implications. The service provider's portal is not an insurmountable obstacle: once the clearance and the wait are documented, an interim application is possible, even inaudita altera parte. The decree is provisional, pending confirmation.
Suspension and new facts. Court of Salerno, R.G. n. 6790/2026
References. Court of Salerno, Specialised Section for immigration, decree on the application of 10 October 2026, R.G. no. 6790/2026.
The facts. The application to suspend the Commission's refusal having been rejected during the court vacation period, the applicant renewed it, producing new evidence: a surgical report compatible with his account and the presence in Italy of a brother holding special protection.
The principle. The decree recalls, with Cass. n. 14851 del 2026, that the application takes effect from the expression of the wish to apply and that it is for the applicant to plead its date. Although there is no reclamo, the uniform interim relief procedure applies to the proceedings: art. 669-septies c.p.c. allows renewal on new grounds, not a re-examination of what has already been argued. Failure to comply with the accelerated procedure entails automatic suspension; in this case those complaints are rejected, but the new documents justify suspension, also in respect of the health aspects of artt. 5, comma 6, and 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act.
Practical implications. The date of the expression of the wish to apply must always be pleaded and proved. If the first application is rejected, new documents open a second route.
European Courts
The week's check. Among the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights published on HUDOC from 26 October to 2 November 2026 none appears to concern immigration or asylum, against Italy or against other States. The official list of press releases of the Court of Justice shows, at the close of this issue, no press releases later than 22 October 2026. Two recent decisions, not reported in issue 1, are covered here.
Minors and detention. ECtHR, B.C. v. Italy, 3 September 2026
In the judgment of 3 September 2026, B.C. v. Italy, application no. 42909/23, the Court found a violation of art. 5 ECHR on account of the detention of a fifteen-year-old unaccompanied minor in the Restinco centre, in Brindisi, without a clear and accessible legal basis. The affair is reconstructed by ASGI.
Practical implications. In cases of minors placed in centres, the legal basis of the de facto deprivation of liberty must be challenged, requesting if necessary an interim measure from the Court.
Temporary protection and asylum. Court of Justice, Case C-249/25, 1 October 2026
According to press release no. 137/26 of the Court of Justice, the automatic suspension of asylum applications of beneficiaries of temporary protection is contrary to Union law. The twelve-month extension of the state of emergency linked to Ukraine, resolved by the Council of Ministers on 28 October, gives the topic current relevance.
From the reviews of the Court of Cassation
The latest thematic review on international protection by the Massimario, covering May and June 2026 and placed on the website on 28 August, reports among others: a) Cass. n. 15548/2026, on integration for the purposes of art. 19, comma 1.1, of the Consolidated Act, to be assessed as a whole and without comparison with the country of origin; b) Cass. n. 21386/2026, which quashes a decision based on the «emotional experience» of an applicant on grounds of sexual orientation, instead of the legal criteria of credibility; c) Cass. n. 20403/2026, on establishing systemic deficiencies in Dublin transfers, in the light of the judgments of the Court of Justice of 19 December 2024, Cases C-185/24 and C-189/24, and of 5 March 2026, Case C-458/24; d) Cass. n. 12492/2026, on the adversarial principle in opposition to expulsion dealt with in writing. These entries report the review: the texts of the orders must be read before they are used in a pleading.
Notes
The case notes are for information purposes only and do not constitute legal advice on any specific case. Decisions of the courts of merit are rulings on individual cases, often interim, and are not binding precedents; their full text was read before each case note was drafted. Quotations from decisions are given in our English translation.
The review is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.
← Back to Immigration case law