Studio Legale Mariani
EN
Contact

Commentary · Immigration case lawImmigration · Validation of detention · From the firm's archive

A pre-printed formula is not enough to take away liberty: the validation judge must look at the alternatives to the C.P.R.

By order no. 13113 of 2023 the Court of Cassation quashed the validation of a detention: a person with a valid passport is entitled to rigorous scrutiny of less restrictive measures.

Avv. Giuseppe MARIANIPublished on 2 November 2026Reading time: 5 minutes

The ruling

Court of Cassation (Corte di cassazione), First Civil Section, order no. 13113 of 2023, decided in chambers on 17 April 2023, published on 12 May 2023, General Register (R.G.) no. 5608/2022. President DE CHIARA, reporting judge SCOTTI

“Art.14, comma 1 bis of the TUI must therefore be interpreted in the light of directive 115/2008 and of EU case law as intended to require rigorous scrutiny of the possibility of adopting measures alternative to detention”

From the firm's archive of orders upholding appeals: appeal argued by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI. The parties are not named.

SentenzeWeb database of the Court of Cassation

The case

In January 2022 a foreign national is detained in the pre-removal detention centre (C.P.R.) of Palazzo San Gervasio. At the hearing his lawyer objects, arguing that the conditions of artt. 13 and 14 of the Consolidated Act were not met and that non-coercive measures should have been applied. The Justice of the Peace of Melfi validates by a measure which merely indicates the need to obtain the documents and to wait for the carriers and holds the conditions to be met. The appeal complains that this was a ready-made printed form, devoid of reasoning.

The decision

The First Section upholds the appeal. The person concerned had stated, without challenge, that he had a valid passport, a necessary condition for the alternative measures of art. 14, comma 1-bis. On the basis of order no. 7829 of 2019 and of the judgment of the Court of Justice of 5 June 2014, Case C-146/14, Mahdi, the Court recalls that the judge must carry out an assessment of proportionality and evaluate whether a less coercive measure can be applied. Detention is permissible only if there is a risk of absconding or if the foreign national avoids or hampers the preparation of return. The Justice of the Peace «disregarded that aspect»: the decree was quashed without referral, since the time limit for validation had expired.

The commentary

Personal liberty is not an administrative concession and cannot be taken away by a formula that is the same for everyone. This is, in my view, the most important lesson of the order. The validation judge is not the Questore's notary: the judge is the guardian of art. 13 of the Constitution, and must look at the person before them, with their history, their documents, the possible alternatives.

It is here that the liberal tradition sets its oldest limit on power: coercion is the last resort, it must be necessary and proportionate, and those who order it must explain the reasons for it. This holds for the citizen and it holds for the foreign national, because the guarantees denied to the weakest grow weaker for everyone. A safe country is not the one that detains the most, but the one that detains only when necessary, and can give its reasons.

Directive 2008/115/EC, on which this reasoning is based, will be repealed with effect from 17 October 2027 by Regulation (EU) 2026/2280 on the common return system. That will be the test: more instruments of coercion require more judicial review, not less.

What changes in practice

Those who receive a detention measure and have a valid passport must say so at once, and have it placed on record: this is the condition for requesting less restrictive measures, such as surrender of the document, an obligation to reside in a given place or regular reporting to the police.

It is the lawyer's task to raise the point expressly at the hearing, having it recorded in the minutes, and to indicate concrete alternatives, so that the silence of the measure becomes a defect open to challenge. The current text of art. 14, amended several times, must always be checked, as must, for future facts, the regime of the new European regulation.

Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI

Potenza, 2 November 2026

Legislative references: art. 13 Cost.; artt. 13 and 14, comma 1-bis, d.lgs. 25 luglio 1998, n. 286; art. 15 Directive 2008/115/EC.

Precedents cited: Cass., sez. I, n. 7829 del 2019; CJEU, 5 June 2014, Case C-146/14, Mahdi, cited in the order.

The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.

← Back to Immigration case law