The ruling
Court of Milan (Tribunale di Milano), Labour Section, judgment no. 4273 of 2026, published on 22 September 2026, General Register (R.G.) no. 7771/2026
The assistants, the Agency itself admits, “do not directly exercise authoritative powers”
Words from the Agency's defence brief, reported in the judgment. Applications were reopened on 20 October 2026; the news was released by ASGI on 29 October 2026.
The case
On 15 May 2026 the Revenue Agency (Agenzia delle Entrate) issues a call for a selection for 622 posts in the assistants' area, professional family of management assistant. The selection is reserved for persons entered on the lists of legge 12 marzo 1999, n. 68, that is, above all, for persons with disabilities who are unemployed and hold a school diploma. Among the requirements, however, is Italian citizenship.
Four organisations, Avvocati per Niente, ASGI, CGIL Lombardia and LEDHA, apply to the employment judge with the action against discrimination. The Agency objects first of all that the ordinary courts lack jurisdiction.
The decision
The Court affirms its own jurisdiction, because the right not to be discriminated against is an absolute subjective right, even when the harm derives from an administrative act. On the merits, it starts from art. 45 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union and from the case law of the Court of Justice, according to which a reservation for nationals is allowed only for posts involving the effective exercise of public powers, and not for preparatory or support activities. Art. 38 of d.lgs. (legislative decree) 30 marzo 2001, n. 165, at commi 1 and 3-bis, extends this regime to family members of Union citizens, to holders of the long-term residence permit and to holders of international protection. A reservation for entire branches or categories is therefore not permissible, and art. 1 of d.P.C.M. (Prime Ministerial Decree) n. 174 del 1994 must be disapplied.
The duties of the assistant, derived from the collective agreement and from the call, are administrative and supportive. The Court recognises a double discrimination: on grounds of nationality, under art. 43 of the Consolidated Immigration Act, and on grounds of disability, because among persons with disabilities entered on the lists an unlawful exclusion of foreign nationals is created, in conflict with the UN Convention and with the judgment of the Court of Justice of 26 January 2021, Case C-16/19.
The Agency was ordered to amend the call, admitting Union citizens and foreign nationals who meet the requirements, with a new time limit of at least thirty days, to publish the judgment on its website and to pay one hundred euros for each day of delay after the thirtieth day from notice. On 20 October 2026 the selection was reopened on the inPA portal, with a deadline of 19 November 2026, at 23:59.
The commentary
The judgment has the merit of separating two things that are all too often confused: citizenship and function. Those who exercise authoritative powers may be bound to the State by a particular tie. Those who carry out administrative support work are not: that work calls for competence, propriety and loyalty to the institution, qualities that do not depend on a passport.
The case also shows how exclusions add up. A person with a disability already encounters obstacles that legge n. 68 del 1999 seeks to remove; if that person was a foreign national living lawfully in Italy, they found themselves excluded from the very selection designed for them. As early as 1998, by judgment no. 454, the Constitutional Court had made clear that foreign workers authorised for stable employment are entitled, on equal terms with citizens, to be entered on the lists for compulsory hiring. Almost thirty years later, a public administration had to be reminded of this by a judge.
The underlying issue remains open. A decree of 1994, which reserves entire administrations for Italian citizens, is disapplied case by case, at the cost of proceedings brought by associations and of competitions held again. The legislature ought to take note and rewrite it, indicating precisely which functions truly require citizenship. The protection of the rights of a few is here also good administration for all: the best are chosen from a wider pool.
What changes in practice
Those who are registered with the targeted employment service (collocamento mirato) and are citizens of another Union State, family members of a Union citizen, or holders of the long-term residence permit or of international protection, and who were excluded by the citizenship requirement, may apply by 23:59 on 19 November 2026, exclusively on the inPA portal. Before doing so they should read the act amending the call, published there on 20 October, which indicates the requirements and any reservations linked to an appeal; a separate procedure is provided for the posts in Bolzano. In case of doubt it is advisable to seek assistance from a lawyer or an association before the deadline, which cannot be recovered.
Lawyers will find in this judgment a working path that is useful for many other calls: the action under art. 44 of the Consolidated Immigration Act, with the procedure under art. 28 of d.lgs. 1° settembre 2011, n. 150; the analytical examination of the duties, rather than only of the administration issuing the call; the request to amend the call with a new time limit, backed by the measure under art. 614-bis c.p.c. (Code of Civil Procedure). When the selection concerns persons with disabilities, this second ground of discrimination must also be pleaded.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 2 November 2026
Legislative references: art. 45 TFEU; art. 38, commi 1 and 3-bis, d.lgs. 30 marzo 2001, n. 165; artt. 43 and 44 d.lgs. 25 luglio 1998, n. 286; art. 28 d.lgs. 1° settembre 2011, n. 150; art. 8 l. 12 marzo 1999, n. 68; art. 1 d.P.C.M. n. 174 del 1994; art. 614-bis c.p.c.; artt. 2, 5 and 27 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
Precedents cited: Corte cost., sent. n. 454 del 1998; CJEU, 26 January 2021, Case C-16/19, and 10 September 2014, Case C-270/13, Haralambidis, cited in the judgment.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.