The ruling
Court of Cassation (Corte di cassazione), First Civil Section, order no. 29557 of 2025, decided in chambers on 25 September 2025, published on 7 November 2025, General Register (R.G.) no. 24478/2024. President ACIERNO, reporting judge IOFRIDA
“The making of the application is material conduct, in free form, to which the legal system attaches the immediate acquisition of a protective status”
From the firm's archive of orders upholding appeals: appeal argued by Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI. The parties are not named.
The case
A foreign national, still at liberty, sends a p.e.c. to the Questura on 10 October 2024 to request the appointment needed to formalise an application for international protection. No one replies. On 21 October he is served with the expulsion decree and the order for detention in the C.P.R. of Palazzo San Gervasio; the Justice of the Peace of Melfi validates it, holding that, since the time limits for the summons had not expired, he could not yet be considered an applicant, and rejects the objection of lack of competence.
The decision
The First Section upholds the appeal and quashes without referral. Citing orders no. 21910 of 2020 and no. 9597 of 2024, it recalls that the «protective status» arises «at the moment of the actual expression of will of the asylum seeker»: the directive distinguishes between the making of the application and its registration by the authority, and the duty to receive the application is the necessary corollary of that expression. Competence for validating the detention of an applicant lies with the specialised section of the Court (Tribunale) and not with the Justice of the Peace. In the case at hand the detention «was null and could not be validated», and since the mandatory time limit for validation had expired the Court decided without referral.
The line of the latest rulings
The order has not remained isolated. By orders nos. 25359, 25360 and 25365 of 15 September 2026 the First Section quashed three validations by the Justice of the Peace of Rome and, deciding on the merits, refused to validate the detention of persons who had expressed the wish to apply for asylum by a p.e.c. not yet followed by formalisation. No. 25359 specifies that this solution is «fully compatible also with the subsequent rules introduced by d.l. n. 100 del 2026». Likewise, order no. 24296 of 31 July 2026 recalls that, even when the request is sent by p.e.c., «the Administration has the duty to receive it», refraining from any measure that would prevent its examination.
The most delicate point is that of removal. Judgment no. 15549 of 21 May 2026 held that an application made at the hearing to validate an escort to the border «must be received by the Justice of the Peace, after being recorded in the minutes, and promptly forwarded to the competent authority». Judgment no. 13625 of 11 May 2026 specified that, save for the exhaustive exceptions in art. 7, comma 2, of d.lgs. n. 25 del 2008 and for cases of an entirely generic application, the forced removal measure cannot be validated, because the applicant has the right to remain in the territory of the State. The reason is clearly stated: a person who asks for protection at that stage «is subject to imminent forced return».
The Milan case
That line is now also followed by the courts of merit. By order of 27 October 2026, R.G. no. 40469/2026, the specialised section of the Court of Milan upheld the urgent application ex art. 700 c.p.c. (Code of Civil Procedure) of a man detained in the C.P.R. of via Corelli, ordering the Questura of Milan to proceed with the receipt and formalisation of his application for international protection. On 14 September his lawyer had written to the centre and then, by p.e.c., to the Questura; on 15 September he had sent a handwritten statement by his client. No reply came. The Ministry relied on the two information sheets (fogli notizie) filled in at the centre, in which protection was not mentioned, but the Court observes that they are a pre-printed form which does not even indicate that option and in which the thoughts of the person concerned are summarised and transcribed by a third party. Citing Cass. n. 21910 del 2020, the court states: «The transmission by pec of the client's expression of will by his lawyer is certainly in due form». The time limits of art. 27 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348, five days from the application, extendable to fifteen in the event of a disproportionate number of requests, had therefore long expired, and the alleged appointment already scheduled, never documented, did not remove the interest in bringing the application.
What is said to have happened next gives the measure of the problem, and it must be reported with due caution, because it comes from a single source, the network Mai più lager, NO ai CPR, which is following the case, and not from a judicial document. According to the account published on 1 November 2026, the day before, the same person was taken to Malpensa airport for return. Half an hour before boarding this person was able to alert the network's helpline, reports went out to various authorities, UNHCR included, it was suggested that the person show the officers the order on a mobile phone, and at the last minute the person was brought back. In an account of 29 October the same network alleges that in the Milan C.P.R. the expression of the wish to apply is put off from day to day and that detainees leave without their lawyers being informed. These are one-sided accusations, which would deserve official verification.
The commentary
A State governed by the rule of law can be recognised by how it treats those with the least strength to defend themselves. Here the administration had received a request, had left it unanswered, and from its own silence had drawn the gravest consequence: the deprivation of liberty of a person who had asked only to be heard. The order overturns this reasoning in simple words. The right arises from the will of the person, not from the diary of an office.
The point goes beyond immigration. If the exercise of a fundamental right depended on the availability of an appointment, the right would no longer belong to the citizen or the foreign national, but to the bureaucracy that grants it. Art. 10, third paragraph, and art. 13 of the Constitution say the opposite: the person comes before the apparatus, and personal liberty can be restricted only in the cases and in the manner provided for by law. An order founded on rules is also one that obliges the administration to be the first to respect them.
But the real test lies outside the courtroom, and the Milan case shows it. A guarantee that arrives after boarding is no guarantee: those who are returned while their application waits to be received lose everything, and no Court of Cassation will give them back the right to be heard. If the facts reported are accurate, not even the order of a judge, issued a few days earlier, stopped the return machine: a telephone call from the airport stopped it. A judicial measure that the administration can ignore until the last minute wounds the rule of law more than any delay. In my experience as a defence lawyer, returns carried out in breach of the law are more widespread than is believed, and often only a lawyer's promptness prevents them. It is not acceptable that the protection of a fundamental right should depend on the good fortune of finding a defence lawyer in time.
The legal framework has meanwhile changed. Since 12 June 2026 the new system of the European Pact has been in operation, and d.l. n. 100 del 2026, converted by legge n. 145 del 2026, has redrawn the subject. The principle, however, remains alive, as confirmed by the September orders and by the immigration case-law review no. 1 with regard to the transitional regime.
What changes in practice
Those who intend to ask for protection should not wait passively for the summons: it is advisable to leave a certain record of their wish, in writing and dated, including through a lawyer or an association, and to keep the receipt. If an expulsion or detention measure then arrives, that proof can make the difference.
Lawyers must produce the p.e.c. from the first hearing and immediately raise the question of the status of applicant and of competence, checking the rules in force on the date of the facts, because the rules have changed several times. When the time limit for validation has expired, quashing without referral must be requested. If return is imminent, every hour counts: the application must be recorded in the minutes of the hearing, communicated to the Questura and to the centre by means that leave a trace and accompanied, if necessary, by an urgent application. Once the measure has been obtained, it is not enough to wait for it to be enforced: it must be sent at once to the Questura and to the centre, and the detained person must have a copy on them.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 2 November 2026
Legislative references: artt. 10, third paragraph, and 13 Cost.; art. 2, comma 1, lett. a), and art. 6, comma 5, d.lgs. 18 agosto 2015, n. 142; artt. 13 and 14 d.lgs. 25 luglio 1998, n. 286; artt. 7, comma 2, and 26 d.lgs. 28 gennaio 2008, n. 25; art. 6, para. 1, Directive 2013/32/EU; art. 27, paras. 1 and 5, Regulation (EU) 2024/1348; artt. 382 and 700 c.p.c.
Precedents cited: Cass. nn. 26523/2009, 21910/2020, 18189/2020, 4120/2024, 9597/2024 and 23993/2025, cited in the order; Cass. nn. 13625, 15549, 24296, 25359, 25360 and 25365 del 2026; Court of Milan, order of 27 October 2026, R.G. n. 40469/2026.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.