Studio Legale Mariani
EN
Contact

Weekly reviewCriminal · Immigration · Civil · Employment

Weekly legal review, 26 October 2026

Studio Legale MarianiPeriod covered: 19-26 October 2026Updated to 26.10.2026
Archived contribution. The review reflects the legislation and case law known on the date indicated and is not updated. Before relying on it in a specific case, the official text in force today should be consulted.

In brief

In criminal matters, the week from 19 to 26 October 2026 is marked by d.l. (decree-law) 22 ottobre 2026, n. 190, which introduces a presumption that a minor over fourteen has the capacity to understand and to will, the new offence of organised violence at public demonstrations and penalties for parents, and by the judgment in which the Court of Justice finds against Hungary and the Czech Republic for questioning suspects without a lawyer. On immigration, the Constitutional Court also adjourns the proceedings brought by the Court of Milan on the employment requirement for social housing, pending the Court of Justice, while the Court of Rome holds that, for the transitional regime of the European Pact, what counts is the date on which the asylum application is expressed and not the date on which it is formalised at the police headquarters (Questura). On the civil side, d.lgs. (legislative decree) n. 194 del 2026 is published in the Official Gazette, transposing the directive against strategic lawsuits against public participation, and the Constitutional Court, with judgment no. 172 of 2026, makes the minimum penalty of 50,000 euros for gambling advertising reducible. In employment matters, judgment no. 174 of 2026 removes the fifteen-employee threshold that limited to six months' pay the compensation for unlawful dismissal of employees hired before 7 March 2015.

On each of these topics Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI signs a commentary in the Legal Watch: criminal, immigration, civil and employment.

New legislation

Criminal. D.L. 22 ottobre 2026, n. 190: public security and juvenile crime

Decree-law no. 190 of 22 October 2026, laying down «Urgent provisions on public security and combating juvenile crime», adopted by the Council of Ministers on 20 October, is published in the Official Gazette, General Series no. 246 of 22 October 2026, and has been in force since 23 October 2026.

Art. 1 adds to the first paragraph of art. 98 c.p. (Criminal Code) the sentence under which, for those who committed the act between the ages of fourteen and eighteen, «the minor's capacity to understand and to will is presumed until proven otherwise»; it provides for an increase in the penalty of one third to one half for the offences under artt. 419 and 420 c.p. committed during demonstrations; it introduces art. 420-bis c.p., «Organised violence at public demonstrations», which punishes with imprisonment from two to five years and a fine from 10,000 to 20,000 euros anyone who, in a group of at least five persons, throws or uses objects capable of causing harm, flares or firecrackers, creating a concrete danger, and with imprisonment from four to twelve years anyone who organises, promotes or incites; it introduces art. 635.1 c.p., «Damage committed by an organised group», which increases by one third to one half the penalty for criminal damage committed by a group of at least five persons, even an occasional one. Art. 2 extends to the offences under artt. 419, 420, 420-bis and 635.1 c.p. the deferred arrest in flagrante delicto provided for by art. 382-bis c.p.p. (Code of Criminal Procedure).

Art. 3 amends the juvenile criminal procedure (d.P.R. 22 settembre 1988, n. 448): in art. 9 it deletes the reference to criminal capacity among the matters to be examined in the inquiries into the minor's personality, allowing the public prosecutor and the court to gather evidence for that purpose (new comma 1-bis); it adds to art. 19, comma 2, the clause «unless the defendant has reached the age of sixteen»; it extends art. 23, comma 1, on pre-trial detention, to the offences under artt. 420-bis and 635.1 c.p. Art. 5 provides for an administrative penalty from 500 to 1,000 euros, and from 1,000 to 2,000 in case of repetition, for the person exercising parental responsibility over a minor, even one lacking criminal capacity, who takes part in the offences listed, unless it is proven that they could not have prevented the act, and allows the prefect to order compensation for damage to public property, with an objection to the court within forty days. Art. 6 introduces into the Anti-Mafia Code an oral warning by the police commissioner (questore) with a ban on gathering, for a maximum of one year, applicable also to minors who have reached the age of fourteen; art. 7 allows the escort to and holding at police offices provided for by art. 11-bis of d.l. n. 59 del 1978 also during prevention operations in crowded places; art. 8 increases by 500 units, until 31 December 2026, the contingent of the Armed Forces deployed in Milan.

Practical implications. The rebuttable presumption of criminal capacity shifts onto the defence the burden of proving the minor's immaturity, and makes it decisive to request the inquiries into personality from the outset. The decree must be converted into law by 21 December 2026. On this topic, see the commentary of the week.

Criminal. D.Lgs. 8 ottobre 2026, n. 188: European production and preservation orders for electronic evidence

The Official Gazette, General Series no. 244 of 20 October 2026, publishes d.lgs. 8 ottobre 2026, n. 188, which completes the alignment with Regulation (EU) 2023/1543 on European production orders and European preservation orders for electronic evidence, supplementing d.lgs. 30 dicembre 2025, n. 215; it enters into force on 4 November 2026. The executing authorities are the public prosecutor and the preliminary investigations judge of the court of the district capital in which the designated establishment or the legal representative of the service provider is located. The person whose data are obtained may challenge the lawfulness, necessity and proportionality of the order: an order of the public prosecutor may be challenged before the preliminary investigations judge (GIP) within ten days of becoming aware of the acquisition, an order of the court under art. 324 c.p.p., and an appeal to the Court of Cassation is allowed only for breach of law (art. 4). Art. 3 provides for financial penalties on service providers from 10,000 to 1,200,000 euros, up to 2 per cent of worldwide turnover in the most serious cases.

Practical implications. The ten-day time limit for challenging the order of the public prosecutor is short and runs from becoming aware of the acquisition: the information given to the person concerned under art. 2 should be checked carefully.

Immigration

No legislative act published during the week amends the Consolidated Immigration Act or the rules on international protection. The measures of d.l. n. 190 del 2026 on escort to police offices and on the oral warning by the police commissioner apply to everyone, citizens and foreign nationals alike, and deserve attention in relation to identification procedures.

Civil. D.Lgs. 8 ottobre 2026, n. 194: protection against strategic lawsuits (SLAPP)

D.lgs. 8 ottobre 2026, n. 194, implementing Directive (EU) 2024/1069 on protecting persons who engage in public participation from manifestly unfounded claims or abusive court proceedings, is published in the Official Gazette, General Series no. 248 of 24 October 2026, and enters into force on 8 November 2026. The decree introduces the application for early dismissal of manifestly unfounded claims (artt. 6-9), security for costs to be provided by the claimant (art. 10), an order to pay, also of the court's own motion, under art. 96, comma 3, c.p.c. (Code of Civil Procedure) and publication of the judgment where the proceedings are abusive (art. 13), intervention by associations and bodies in support of the defendant (art. 5) and an action for damages against abusive proceedings brought in third countries (art. 14). It applies only to civil and commercial matters with cross-border implications, excluding those in which claimant and defendant are both domiciled in Italy (art. 3, comma 3), and to proceedings brought after its entry into force (art. 17).

Practical implications. The application for early dismissal must be filed within the time limits for entering an appearance and served within ten days. On the limitation concerning domestic cases, see the commentary of the week.

The Official Gazette, General Series no. 245 of 21 October 2026, also publishes d.lgs. 7 ottobre 2026, n. 189, which transposes Directive (EU) 2024/2810 on multiple-vote share structures in companies that seek admission to trading on multilateral trading facilities and aligns Italian law with Regulation (EU) 2024/2809.

Employment

In Official Gazette no. 246 of 22 October 2026, ARAN gives notice of the framework agreement on trade union leave for the three-year period 2025-2027, concerning public employment. No legislative act of the week affects the rules on private employment relationships.

European Union law

Criminal. CJEU, Cases C-660/24 and C-681/24: questioning without a lawyer

In two judgments of 22 October 2026 the Court of Justice upheld the infringement actions brought by the Commission against Hungary and the Czech Republic (press release no. 152/26). The national laws allowed a suspect to be questioned without a lawyer if the lawyer did not appear within a time limit, of two hours in Hungary and forty-eight hours in the Czech Republic. The Court recalled that Directive 2013/48/EU guarantees, in principle, the physical presence of the lawyer during questioning and that the grounds for temporary derogation are listed exhaustively; Hungary was also found not to have transposed the rules on waiver of the right to a lawyer.

Practical implications. The ruling strengthens objections that statements made without the effective assistance of a lawyer are inadmissible, including in summary trials (direttissima) and in relation to arrested foreign nationals, for whom the right to an interpreter is added to the right to a lawyer.

Civil. Opinion of Advocate General Rantos on the solidarity contribution of energy companies

On 22 October 2026 Advocate General Rantos concluded, in Cases C-358/24, Varo Energy Belgium, C-533/24, Vermilion Energy Ireland, and C-153/25, Acea Produzione, that the temporary solidarity contribution on the windfall profits of energy companies, introduced in response to the crisis that followed the war in Ukraine, is compatible with EU law (press release no. 153/26).

Also worth pointing out, although it predates the week, is the judgment of 15 October 2026 in Case C-70/25, according to which, in cases of phishing, the bank must immediately refund the unauthorised transaction even where the customer is alleged to have been grossly negligent, and may then take action to recover the sum (press release no. 147/26).

Practical implications. Judgment C-70/25 is an immediate tool for account holders who are victims of online fraud, who can demand that their account be re-credited without waiting for the outcome of the dispute over their diligence.

Case law

Criminal. Corte cost., ord. n. 177 del 2026: suspension of enforcement and less serious child pornography

With order no. 177 of 2026, filed on 22 October 2026 (drafting judge Patroni Griffi), the Constitutional Court declared manifestly inadmissible, for lack of reasoning on relevance, the questions raised by the Court of Appeal of Turin on art. 4-bis, comma 1-quater, of the Prison Administration Act (ord. pen.), referred to in art. 656, comma 9, lett. a), c.p.p., insofar as it excludes suspension of the enforcement of short sentences for the offence under art. 600-ter c.p. even where the mitigating circumstance of lesser seriousness is recognised (official record). The conviction also concerned aggravated sexual violence under art. 609-ter c.p., which in itself bars suspension, and the referring court had not explained why this was not relevant.

Practical implications. The question, similar to the one raised by the Court of Ancona and reported in the review of 19 October, remains open on the merits and may be raised again in proceedings in which the conviction concerns art. 600-ter c.p. alone.

Criminal. Cass. pen., sez. VI, n. 36318 del 2026: refusal of surrender and enforcement of the sentence in Italy

With judgment no. 36318, decided on 14 October and filed on 15 October 2026 (President De Amicis, Judge Rapporteur Biondi), published on the Court's website during the week, the Sixth Section held that, when the executing State refuses the surrender requested under a European arrest warrant for the enforcement of a custodial sentence, because of the risk of inhuman or degrading prison conditions, it is required to ask the issuing State to forward the judgment of conviction, together with the certificate provided for by art. 4, paragraph 5, of Framework Decision 2008/909/JHA, in order to recognise it and enforce the sentence on its own territory (official record).

Practical implications. Protection against inhuman treatment does not translate into impunity, but into enforcement of the sentence in Italy, a solution that also favours the social reintegration of a convicted person who is resident here.

Criminal. Joint Sections: where to file the request under art. 628-bis c.p.p.

With order no. 35770 of 2026, appeal R.G. no. 15007/2026 was referred to the Joint Criminal Sections (Sezioni Unite penali) and set down for the hearing of 17 December 2026 (official record). The question is whether the request for removal of the prejudicial effects of decisions adopted in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights, provided for by art. 628-bis c.p.p., must be filed, on pain of inadmissibility, with the registry of the Court of Appeal or with that of the Court of Cassation, when it seeks the revocation of both the Cassation judgment and the appeal judgment. The hearing of the Joint Sections on whether a refusal to lift a preventive seizure can be challenged, reported in the previous review, remains set for 26 November 2026.

Practical implications. Until the decision, as a precaution, it is advisable to file the request with the Court of Cassation while also referring to the appeal judgment, or in any event to check the practice of the competent registry.

Criminal. European Court of Human Rights: Berlusconi v. Italy

With the judgment of 22 October 2026, Berlusconi v. Italy, application no. 8683/14, the Court found no violation of art. 6 ECHR, holding that a lack of impartiality of the Court of Cassation had not been shown in the proceedings that had made final the conviction for tax fraud linked to the purchase of television rights (official page of the Court).

Immigration. Corte cost., ordd. nn. 175 e 176 del 2026: social housing and employment requirement

After order no. 175 of 2026, by which the Court referred to the Court of Justice the question of the validity of the derogation from equal treatment provided for by Directive 2011/98/EU (on which see the commentary of 24 October 2026), with order no. 176 of 2026, filed on the same day, 22 October (drafting judge Navarretta), the Court also adjourned to a later date the proceedings brought by the Court of Milan on art. 40, comma 6, of the Consolidated Immigration Act and on art. 22, comma 1, lett. a), of Lombardy Regional Law no. 16 of 2016, which require foreign nationals to be in employment in order to access public residential housing (official record).

Practical implications. Both proceedings are awaiting the Court of Justice: in the meantime, exclusions from rankings based solely on the lack of a current job should be challenged without letting the time limits expire.

Immigration. Court of Rome: transitional regime of the Pact and date of the asylum application

In two judgments of the Section for personal rights and immigration, of 29 September 2026 (R.G. no. 24772/2026) and no. 14179 published on 13 October 2026 (R.G. no. 25435/2026), made known on 20 October by Melting Pot Europa, the Court of Rome held that, for the purposes of art. 79, paragraph 3, of Regulation (EU) 2024/1348 and of art. 17, comma 4, of d.l. n. 100 del 2026, the application for protection is deemed to have been made from the moment the wish to apply is expressed, including by p.e.c. (certified e-mail) from the lawyer, and not from its formalisation at the police headquarters, because otherwise the administration's delay would determine the applicable regime; it therefore ordered the Ministry of the Interior to formalise the applications and declared one of them subject to Directive 2013/32/EU.

Practical implications. The date on which the application was expressed should be documented and produced in every proceeding. On this topic, see the commentary of the week.

Immigration. The other decisions reported

The Court of Appeal of Rome, Labour Section, in judgment no. 3775 of 24 September 2026, held that a foreign national who is lawfully staying and resident in Italy need not produce a specific certification of income earned in the country of nationality in order to obtain the social allowance (assegno sociale), since they are already required to declare in Italy all their income, wherever produced; the Regional Administrative Court (T.A.R.) for Veneto, Section III, in judgment no. 1777 of 8 September 2026, annulled the refusal by which the Prefecture of Rovigo had denied a worker who entered on a seasonal visa the takeover by a new employer, after the employer who had applied for the work clearance (nulla osta) had never made himself available; both rulings were published by Melting Pot Europa (the second one here) during the week. On 23 October 2026 the Massimario Office of the Court of Cassation published a thematic review on international and complementary protection, devoted to persecution for political opinion and sur place protection.

Practical implications. The Massimario's review is a useful reference for appeals based on political activity carried out in Italy after departure, including on social networks.

Civil. Corte cost., sent. n. 172 del 2026: minimum penalty for gambling advertising

With judgment no. 172 of 2026, filed on 20 October 2026 (drafting judge Sciarrone Alibrandi), the Court declared unconstitutional art. 9, comma 2, of d.l. 12 luglio 2018, n. 87, converted by legge 9 agosto 2018, n. 96, insofar as it provides that the penalty for advertising games with cash prizes is «in any case not less than 50,000 euros for each violation», allowing a lower penalty in case of manifest disproportion with respect to the seriousness of the violation, the conduct of the offender, their personality and their financial situation (official record). In the main proceedings, brought before the T.A.R. of Lazio, a content creator who had earned about 1,000 euros had been given a total penalty of 157,000 euros.

Practical implications. The judgment confirms that administrative penalties of a punitive nature are subject to the principle of proportionality, an argument that can be used in objections to penalties with high statutory minimums.

Civil. Court of Cassation: two questions referred

Cass. civ., sez. I, interlocutory order of 22 October 2026, no. 27546 (President Ferro, Judge Rapporteur D'Orazio), made a preliminary reference to the Court of Justice on whether the cram-down confirmation of a composition with creditors (concordato preventivo) under art. 180 of the Bankruptcy Law (l. fall.), despite the decisive vote against by the tax authorities, is compatible with Directive (EU) 2019/1023 and with the rules on State aid (official record). Cass. civ., sez. II, interlocutory order of 21 October 2026, no. 27417 (President Scarpa, Judge Rapporteur Trapuzzano), referred to the First President, for possible assignment to the Joint Sections, the question whether a Cassation ruling that merely corrects the reasoning under art. 384, last paragraph, c.p.c. can be revoked under art. 391-ter c.p.c. (official record). With order no. 173 of 2026 the Constitutional Court declared inadmissible the intervention of a third party in the proceedings on art. 51, comma 4, of the Electronic Communications Code (official record).

Practical implications. In compositions with a tax settlement, order no. 27546 of 2026 opens a European front that may affect confirmations still pending.

Employment. Corte cost., sent. n. 174 del 2026: dismissals in small businesses

With judgment no. 174 of 2026, decided on 6 July and filed on 22 October 2026 (President Amoroso, drafting judge Sciarrone Alibrandi), the Court, on a question raised by the Court of Livorno, declared unconstitutional art. 8 of legge 15 luglio 1966, n. 604, limited to the words «, if employed by an employer with more than fifteen employees» (official record). It follows that employees hired before 7 March 2015 by employers below the threshold may also obtain the increased compensation of up to 10 months' pay, with more than ten years' service, and up to 14 months' pay, with more than twenty years' service.

Practical implications. The ruling applies to pending proceedings. On this topic, see the commentary of the week.

Employment. Cass. civ., sez. lav., ord. interl. n. 27395 del 2026: pension under the international system and top-up to the minimum

By interlocutory order of 20 October 2026 (President Esposito, Judge Rapporteur Magnanensi) the Labour Section asked the Court of Justice whether art. 58 of Regulation (EC) no. 883/2004 requires an independent foreign benefit to be added to the Italian pension calculated under the international pro rata system in order to determine entitlement to the top-up to the minimum provided for by art. 8 of Law no. 153 of 1969 (official record).

Practical implications. The question concerns workers, including migrants, whose contribution records are split between several States, and suggests not allowing decisions revoking or refusing the top-up to become final.

The legal profession

Year-end deadlines

The deadlines recalled in the previous review remain unchanged: by 31 December 2026 the fifteen training credits for the year must be obtained, three of them in the compulsory subjects, in accordance with resolution no. 916 of 21 November 2025 of the National Bar Council (CNF), and the second instalment of the self-assessed contributions of Mod. 5/2026 must be paid (explanatory notes of Cassa Forense). In Official Gazette no. 246 of 22 October 2026 the Ministry of Labour gives notice of the approval of resolution no. 253 adopted by Cassa Forense on 22 May 2026.

Abusive lawsuits: the role of associations

D.lgs. n. 194 del 2026 allows associations and collective bodies to intervene in support of the defendant in abusive lawsuits against public participation: it is an opportunity for Bar Councils and lawyers' associations to offer qualified assistance to journalists, committees and human rights defenders.

The review is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.

← Back to the archive