The ruling
Constitutional Court (Corte costituzionale), judgment no. 174 of 2026, decided on 6 July 2026 and filed on 22 October 2026. President AMOROSO, drafting judge SCIARRONE ALIBRANDI
The Court declares art. 8 of Law of 15 July 1966, no. 604, unconstitutional insofar as it contains the words “, if employed by an employer with more than fifteen employees”
Question raised by the Court of Livorno (Tribunale di Livorno), sitting as labour court, by order of 12 February 2026.
The case
Art. 8 of Law of 15 July 1966, no. 604, governs the consequences of unjustified dismissal in businesses that do not reach the thresholds of art. 18 of the Workers’ Statute (Statuto dei lavoratori), for those hired before 7 March 2015, the date from which d.lgs. (legislative decree) 4 marzo 2015, n. 23, applies. The employer may choose between re-hiring the worker and paying compensation of between 2.5 and 6 months’ pay; the provision allowed increases up to 10 months’ pay for those with more than ten years’ service and up to 14 for those with more than twenty, but only if the employer had more than fifteen employees.
In practice, for an employee of a small business the cap remained six months’ pay, whatever their length of service. The Court of Livorno doubted the legitimacy of that limit and asked the Constitutional Court to raise it to twelve months’ pay.
The decision
The Court upheld the question, but with an intervention different from the one requested: it did not replace the number, it removed the condition. Now that the words making the increases subject to the fifteen-employee requirement have fallen, a worker in a small business, too, if they have more than ten or more than twenty years’ service, can obtain compensation of up to 10 or up to 14 months’ pay.
The reasoning forms part of a long line of case law. Already in judgment no. 194 of 2018 the Court had held that compensation for unlawful dismissal must be personalised, adequate and dissuasive; in judgment no. 183 of 2022 it had warned that the legislature’s inaction on the regime for small businesses could not continue indefinitely; in judgment no. 118 of 2025 it had removed the six-month cap for those hired from 7 March 2015. The Court now observes that the six-month limit «excessively compresses the amount of the compensation» and that the size requirement is the real obstacle to compensation capable of ensuring «adequate dissuasion of the employer from dismissing unjustly». The number of employees remains a criterion that the court takes into account, but it is no longer a barrier.
The commentary
The judgment removes a disparity that no longer had any justification. A worker hired by a small business before 2015 found themselves, paradoxically, less protected than a colleague hired afterwards, to whom judgment no. 118 of 2025 had already restored proportionate compensation. Twenty years of work were worth, in the event of unjust dismissal, as much as two.
The Court’s choice not to rewrite the amount, but to remove only the size condition, respects the legislature’s discretion and, at the same time, gives back to the court what belongs to it: assessing the specific case, length of service, the conduct of the parties and the size of the business, without a rigid cap that turns compensation into a fixed tariff.
There remains a message for Parliament. For years the Court has pointed out that the rules on dismissals in small businesses should be rethought as a whole, bearing in mind that the number of employees no longer says much about a business’s economic strength. Constitutional case law has done its part; it is now up to the legislature to give workers and businesses clear rules.
What changes in practice
For workers. Those hired before 7 March 2015 by an employer with no more than fifteen employees, who have more than ten years’ service and have been dismissed without just cause or justified reason, can now claim compensation higher than six months’ pay. The dismissal must be challenged in writing within sixty days and, within the following one hundred and eighty days, an application must be filed with the court or a conciliation attempt requested: anyone still within the time limits, or with a case pending, should have their position examined straight away.
For colleagues. The ruling applies to pending proceedings, in which an award above six months’ pay should be sought, including in the final written submissions, pleading length of service and the other criteria of art. 8. In proceedings concluded by a judgment that has become final (res judicata), the declaration of unconstitutionality has no effect. For employers, the new exposure suggests reassessing settlement proposals in pending disputes, particularly with longer-serving employees.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 26 October 2026
Legislative references: art. 8 l. 15 luglio 1966, n. 604; art. 18 l. 20 maggio 1970, n. 300; artt. 6 and 9 d.lgs. 4 marzo 2015, n. 23; artt. 3, 4, 35, 41 and 117, first paragraph, Cost., in relation to art. 24 of the European Social Charter.
Precedents cited: Corte cost., sentt. nn. 194 del 2018, 150 del 2020, 183 del 2022 and 118 del 2025, cited in the judgment.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.