The ruling
Court of Cassation, Civil Joint Sections, judgment no. 28296 of 2026, public hearing of 26 May 2026, published on 3 November 2026, R.G. n. 19300/2024. President D'ASCOLA, judge rapporteur CAMPESE
“The protection of the senior doctor, therefore, remains within the employment relationship and takes the form of employer liability”
The Court adds that, where the maximum limits of Directive 2003/88/EC are exceeded, the damage from psychophysical exhaustion is in re ipsa.
The case
Some National Health Service doctors claim compensation from the Presidency of the Council of Ministers for having worked, between 2008 and 2015, weekly hours and rest periods not in line with Directive 2003/88/EC. They accuse the State of failing to bring the legal order into line: art. 3, comma 85, of law n. 244 del 2007 and art. 41, comma 13, of d.l. n. 112 del 2008 had excluded senior hospital doctors from the limits on weekly working time and daily rest of d.lgs. n. 66 del 2003, until their repeal by law n. 161 del 2014, following infringement proceedings opened by the European Commission.
The claim is dismissed at first instance and on appeal; the Rome Court of Appeal rules by judgment of 12 February 2024. The Employment Section, having noted a latent conflict with the Third Section, refers the question to the Joint Sections.
The decision
The Joint Sections dismiss the appeal. The directive, they observe, guarantees eleven consecutive hours of rest in every twenty-four and an average of forty-eight hours a week, but builds these protections on a broad system of derogations, also entrusted to collective bargaining, particularly for hospital services. The domestic provisions of 2007 and 2008 left it to the collective agreements to define arrangements capable of ensuring appropriate protection and recovery, and the 2008 collective agreement provided for rest after on-call duty and night shifts. Neither the infringement proceedings, closed without a judgment of the Court of Justice, nor the subsequent repeal in themselves demonstrate a serious and manifest breach, which is the precondition for State liability.
The Court, however, does not leave the doctors without protection. It specifies that the worker's consent to exceeding the limits «can in no case operate ad nutum and ad libitum», that exceeding the maximum limits of the directive always gives rise to compensation, with damage from psychophysical exhaustion in re ipsa, and that the employer, namely the local health authority, is liable for that damage under art. 2087 of the Civil Code. Costs are set off, given the complexity of the questions and the lack of uniformity in the case law.
The commentary
Behind a technical question, State liability for the faulty transposition of a directive, lies a reality everyone knows: doctors coming off a night on call and going back to the ward, shifts that get longer because staff are lacking, fatigue that becomes a risk, for those who provide care and for those who receive it. The limit on working hours is not a professional privilege. It is, as the Court itself recalls citing European case law, a social right aimed at protecting health.
The solution adopted by the Joint Sections is open to debate. Regarding as not serious a derogation which, as the Commission had pointed out when opening the infringement proceedings, extended to all National Health Service doctors, classified as senior staff even without top-level positions, leaves more than one doubt, and it is significant that the Third Section had found those rules not compliant. But the judgment has a merit that should not be underestimated: it moves the centre of gravity of protection to where the damage occurs, in the employment relationship, and states clearly that the damage from exhaustion need not be proved in its precise amount, because it is inherent in exceeding the limits.
The message to the health authorities is clear. Organising wards by relying on doctors' unlimited availability, or on a consent that the Court declares worthless unless it is circumscribed, exposes them to liability. The health of those who work and the safety of care are the same thing seen from two sides.
What changes in practice
A doctor who has worked beyond the European limits, or without the rest due, cannot claim compensation from the State for the provisions of the 2008-2015 period, but can bring an action against their own health authority. It is important to keep shift rosters, attendance sheets, service orders and every document on on-call and stand-by duty, bearing in mind that monetary claims are subject to limitation periods.
For lawyers, the judgment shows the way: the action must be based on art. 2087 of the Civil Code and on the actual exceeding of the statutory or contractual limits, against the employer, and not on the liability of the State as legislator. The damage from psychophysical exhaustion is recognised in re ipsa when the maximum limits are exceeded; what remains is to allege and prove precisely the exceeding of the limits, hour by hour and shift by shift, and to contest any consent given by the worker, which cannot count as an open-ended waiver.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 9 November 2026
Legislative references: arts. 32 and 36 Cost.; art. 31 Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union; arts. 3, 6, 17, 18 and 22 Directive 2003/88/EC; arts. 4 and 7 d.lgs. 8 aprile 2003, n. 66; art. 3, comma 85, l. 24 dicembre 2007, n. 244; art. 41, comma 13, d.l. 25 giugno 2008, n. 112; art. 14 l. 30 ottobre 2014, n. 161; art. 15, comma 3, d.lgs. 30 dicembre 1992, n. 502; art. 2087 c.c.
Precedents cited: Cass., sez. III, nn. 18381 and 18382 del 2025; Cass., sez. lav., ord. interl. n. 30777 del 2025; Court of Justice, 9 September 2003, Case C-151/02, Jaeger; Court of Justice, Case C-243/09, Fuß; Court of Justice, Grand Chamber, 24 March 2026, Case C-767/23, Remling.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.