In brief
The week from 2 to 9 November 2026 is marked by three rulings that speak of freedom and safeguards. The Constitutional Court, by judgment no. 181, abolishes mandatory imprisonment for military defamation and brings those acts back under the ordinary rules. The Civil Joint Sections, by judgment no. 28375, require the question of jurisdiction to be decided first and recognise the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts over the rights of honorary judges arising from European law; by judgment no. 28296 they rule out State liability for the derogation on the working hours of senior hospital doctors, but point out that exceeding the European limits is always compensable damage chargeable to the employer. On immigration, the directive of the Minister of the Interior of 3 November 2026 on fitness examinations for detention has not yet been published, and the Court of Cassation reaffirms that the status of asylum applicant arises with the expression of the intention to apply. On the legislative side, d.l. n. 200 del 2026 extends the functions of ANAC and the Council of Ministers challenges the Veneto regional law on medically assisted suicide.
New legislation
Criminal
No act published in the Official Gazettes from no. 255 of 2 November to no. 260 of 7 November 2026 amends the Criminal Code or the Code of Criminal Procedure. D.l. 22 ottobre 2026, n. 190, on public security and juvenile crime, must be converted into law by 21 December 2026.
Immigration
No act of the week in the Official Gazette amends the Consolidated Act on Immigration or the rules on international protection. The directive of the Minister of the Interior of 3 November 2026, which replaces art. 3 of the directive of 19 May 2022 on fitness examinations for admission to pre-removal detention centres, has not been published either in the Gazette or, as checked on 9 November 2026, in the “Amministrazione trasparente” section of the Ministry.
Practical implications. Until it is published, the text is known only from the passages reported in the press; the law prohibiting the detention of persons whose health conditions are incompatible with it has not changed. On this subject, see the commentary of the week.
Civil. D.l. n. 200 del 2026 and the resolutions of the Council of Ministers
The Official Gazette no. 259 of 6 November 2026 publishes d.l. 6 novembre 2026, n. 200, in force from 7 November, under which the president and members of the National Anti-Corruption Authority appointed in 2020 continue to exercise their functions, limited to acts of ordinary administration and to those that are urgent and cannot be deferred, until the new members are appointed and in any event for no more than forty-five days. In the same Gazette the Court of Cassation announces the popular-initiative bill «Guarantee of the voter's personal choice and equal access to elections», promoted on 5 November 2026.
The Council of Ministers no. 196 of 5 November 2026 resolved to challenge before the Constitutional Court the law of the Veneto Region of 8 September 2026, no. 17, «Procedures for regional health care assistance for medically assisted suicide», with reference, among others, to arts. 2, 3, 32, 97, 117 and 123 of the Constitution; it gave final approval to the legislative decree implementing Directive (EU) 2024/2881 on ambient air quality, not yet published.
Practical implications. On end-of-life matters the decision now passes to the Constitutional Court; until it rules the Veneto law remains in force, but anyone intending to rely on it should know that its fate is under discussion.
Employment. Family caregivers and labour costs
The Official Gazette no. 260 of 7 November 2026 the Presidency of the Council of Ministers gives notice of the publication, on the institutional websites, of the decree of the Minister for Disabilities of 12 June 2026 on measures recognising the social and economic value of the non-professional care work of family caregivers, funded for 2026 by the Single Fund for the Inclusion of Persons with Disabilities. In issue no. 255 of 2 November 2026 the Ministry of Labour publishes the average hourly labour cost for employees in the metalworking and plant installation industry, effective from June 2026. The legislative decree on platform work, approved on 28 October, does not yet appear in the Gazettes from no. 255 to no. 260.
Practical implications. Families caring for a person with a disability should follow the regional and municipal calls that implement the caregiver decree. The average hourly cost is the reference parameter in public procurement and in assessing whether tenders are appropriate.
European Union law
Criminal. European arrest warrant and proportionality of the sentence: Court of Justice, Case C-583/24
In its judgment of 3 November 2026, Case C-583/24, Tagu, the Court of Justice held that the alleged disproportion between the sentence imposed and the seriousness of the offence, even where there are significant differences between the laws of the Member States, is not in itself sufficient to refuse to execute a European arrest warrant; refusal is possible only exceptionally, following the two-stage examination of systemic or generalised deficiencies and of the concrete risk to the person, for example where the law of the issuing State allows sentences so disproportionate as to amount to inhuman or degrading punishment, or does not allow the court to take account of the seriousness of the offence (press release no. 154/26).
Practical implications. Defence counsel opposing surrender must document deficiencies in the system of the issuing State and their bearing on the specific case, not merely the difference in sentence.
Case law
Criminal. Corte cost., sent. n. 181 del 2026: military defamation punishable only by imprisonment is unconstitutional
By judgment no. 181 of 2026, decided on 10 June and filed on 3 November 2026 (judge rapporteur Luciani), the Court declared unconstitutional art. 227, first and second paragraphs, of the Military Criminal Code in Peacetime and, consequentially, the third paragraph: a purely custodial penalty for conduct substantially overlapping with ordinary defamation is not necessary and has a chilling effect on freedom of expression; the conduct now falls under art. 595 c.p. (text in the Official Gazette, 1st special series, no. 44 of 4 November 2026).
Practical implications. In pending proceedings, it must be argued that the special provision has ceased to apply, and the question of jurisdiction must be raised. On this subject, see the commentary of the week.
Criminal. Corte cost., sent. n. 180 del 2026: no probation for trafficking in unlawful influence and interference with the freedom of the tendering procedure
By judgment no. 180 of 2026, heard on 23 September and filed on 2 November 2026 (judge rapporteur Sandulli), the Court declared unfounded the questions concerning art. 168-bis, first paragraph, c.p., raised by the Judge for the Preliminary Hearing of Pescara, insofar as it does not allow proceedings to be suspended with probation for the offences under arts. 346-bis and 353-bis c.p.: the offences put forward for comparison are not homogeneous (text in the Official Gazette).
Criminal. Cass. pen., sez. VI, n. 38233 del 2026: domestic abuse and futile motives
By judgment no. 38233, heard on 16 September and filed on 3 November 2026 (President Di Stefano, judge rapporteur Di Nicola Travaglini), the Sixth Section held that in domestic abuse the aggravating circumstance of futile motives under art. 61, first paragraph, no. 1, c.p. applies where the violence is aimed at preventing the victim from exercising basic individual rights and freedoms that the offender claims to subject to their control, and that it is irrelevant that the conduct stems from cultural or religious beliefs incompatible with the fundamental principles of the legal order, which presuppose the subordination of women to men (official record).
Practical implications. A person's freedom in everyday life, to go out, to work, to dress, to see whomever they wish, is an interest the law protects against any claim to control, whatever the stated justification.
Immigration. The Court of Cassation on the status of applicant and on manifest unfoundedness
By order no. 28221, published on 2 November 2026, the First Section refused on the merits to validate a detention: a person who has expressed the intention to apply for asylum is an applicant, and it is for the administration to prove the summons and the person's awareness of the consequences of failing to appear in order to argue an implicit withdrawal. By order no. 28337, published on 3 November, it specified that, once the application has been rejected as manifestly unfounded and the application for suspension dismissed, the mere pendency of the proceedings does not prevent measures to enforce the expulsion. The case notes are in the immigration case-law review no. 3.
Immigration. Ministry of Defence competition reopened to foreign nationals
On 5 November 2026 the Ministry of Defence published on the inPA portal the partial amendment of the call for applications for 1,100 assistants and the reopening of the time limits, ordered solely in order to comply with the operative part of the judgment of the Court of Milan, employment section, no. 5127 of 29 October 2026: citizens of the Union and of third countries holding the residence documents under art. 38, commi 1 and 3-bis, of d.lgs. n. 165 del 2001 may now take part. The Ministry states that compliance does not amount to acquiescence.
Practical implications. Those who meet the requirements should check the reopened time limit on the inPA portal and submit their application.
Immigration. Citizenship of minors born abroad before the Constitutional Court and the Court of Justice
The Court of Avellino, by order of 18 September 2026, entered as no. 176 in the 2026 register of referral orders, raised a question of constitutionality concerning art. 3-bis of law n. 91 del 1992, introduced by d.l. n. 36 del 2025, and made a preliminary reference to the Court of Justice, in the case of minors born abroad, children of citizens whose status had been established by a final judgment. The case note is in immigration case-law review no. 3.
Civil. Cass. civ., sez. un., n. 28375 del 2026: jurisdiction first
By judgment no. 28375, heard on 23 June and published on 3 November 2026 (President D'Ascola, judge rapporteur Ponterio), the Joint Sections held that the cross-appeal of the party successful on jurisdiction is conditional de iure only if the main appeal appears, on a preliminary examination, inadmissible or manifestly unfounded; in other cases jurisdiction must be decided first. They recognised the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts over the claims of an honorary judge based on Directives 97/81/EC and 1999/70/EC (official record).
Practical implications. The approach to the cross-appeal on jurisdiction changes. On this subject, see the commentary of the week.
Civil. Corte cost., sent. n. 182 del 2026: the essential level of assistance for pupils with disabilities requires agreement with the regional and local authorities
By judgment no. 182 of 2026, decided on 22 September and filed on 3 November 2026 (judge rapporteur Antonini), on applications by the Regions of Puglia and Emilia-Romagna, the Court declared unconstitutional art. 1, comma 707, second sentence, and comma 708, second sentence, of the 2026 budget law, n. 199 del 2025, insofar as they do not provide for agreement in the Unified Conference on the definition of the essential level of services for the autonomy and communication assistance of pupils with disabilities and of the related criteria (text in the Official Gazette).
Practical implications. Families of pupils with disabilities should know that the autonomy and communication assistance service remains due; the judgment concerns the way in which the State and the regional and local authorities define its content and resources.
Employment. Cass. civ., sez. un., n. 28296 del 2026: working hours of senior hospital doctors and State liability
By judgment no. 28296, heard on 26 May and published on 3 November 2026 (President D'Ascola, judge rapporteur Campese), the Joint Sections ruled out that the provisions which until 2015 exempted senior doctors of the National Health Service from the limits on weekly working time and daily rest amounted to a serious and manifest breach of Union law capable of giving rise to State liability, without prejudice to the employer's liability for actually exceeding the limits (official record).
Practical implications. The action must be brought against the local health authority. On this subject, see the commentary of the week.
Employment. Inclusion allowance and good-character requirements before the Constitutional Court
The Court of Caltagirone, by order of 10 August 2026, entered as no. 174 in the 2026 register of referral orders, raised a question of constitutionality concerning the good-character requirements laid down for the inclusion allowance.
European Court of Human Rights
Among the judgments published on HUDOC from 2 to 5 November 2026 there are none against Italy. On expulsion, in its judgment of 5 November 2026, A.M. v. Bulgaria, application no. 23441/25, the Court found that removal to Uzbekistan would violate art. 3 of the Convention. The data are taken from HUDOC; the full text should be read before drawing conclusions for a specific case.
The legal profession
Reform of the legal profession
The Official Gazette no. 260 of 7 November 2026 publishes the corrigendum to the notice on the preparatory work for law 28 luglio 2026, n. 137, delegating to the Government the reform of the legal profession: the Senate bill is no. 1917.
The review is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.
← Back to the archive