The ruling
Constitutional Court, judgment no. 193 of 2026, decided on 8 June 2026, filed on 10 November 2026, published in the Official Gazette, 1st special series, no. 45 of 11 November 2026. Judge rapporteur SAN GIORGIO
“Rules that ensure an adequate legal basis for the needs set out, all the more urgent in view of the central place of personal liberty in the constitutional design”
The Court takes up the words of judgment no. 96 of 2025 and renews its call on the legislature to regulate the manner of detention by law.
The case
The Court of Appeal of Lecce, immigration section, sitting as a single judge, called upon in 2025 to validate the detention, or the extension of detention, of foreign nationals who had applied for international protection while already detained in the pre-removal detention centre, raises various questions of constitutionality in thirteen orders.
It challenges first of all the choice made by d.l. n. 145 del 2024, converted by law n. 187 del 2024, to assign those validations to the Court of Appeal instead of to the specialised section of the district court. It then complains that the law does not regulate the manner of detention of asylum applicants, leaving it to secondary sources and to the discretion of the administration, in breach of the statutory reservation in art. 13 of the Constitution; and that the detainee does not have full and immediate access to a lawyer, who learns of the proceedings only through the decree setting the hearing.
The decision
The Court observes at the outset that d.l. 12 giugno 2026, n. 100, converted by law 7 agosto 2026, n. 145, returned to the specialised sections jurisdiction over the validation of the detention of applicants and provided for an appeal to the Court of Cassation under the Code of Civil Procedure. The new rules, however, do not apply to the proceedings under examination, both because of the principle tempus regit actum and because art. 17, comma 4, of the decree retains the previous rules for proceedings initiated following applications submitted before 12 June 2026.
The questions on the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal are declared in part manifestly unfounded and in part unfounded, on the basis of judgment no. 205 of 2025: the transfer, although it sacrifices concentration and uniformity, is a discretionary choice that does not cross into manifest unreasonableness. The objections concerning the rights of the defence are also unfounded: citing judgment no. 78 of 2026, the Court rules out that the position of the detainee can be equated with that of an arrested person, because the foreign national «is not accused of an offence», and recalls that the law ensures the participation of defence counsel at the hearing and the notification of the Questore's measure in a language the person concerned understands.
On art. 13 of the Constitution, by contrast, the questions are declared inadmissible, but for a reason that weighs more than a finding of unconstitutionality. The Court recalls judgment no. 96 of 2025, which had already found that the reference in art. 14 of the Consolidated Act to a regulation and to prefectural measures «in no way satisfies the absolute reservation» of law, because it leaves «almost the entire regulation of the matter to regulatory provisions and to discretionary administrative measures». That gap cannot be filled by the Court, either with European directives or with the Prison Administration Act, because administrative detention must remain free of any punitive character. It is for the legislature.
The commentary
After judgment no. 96 of 2025, the Constitutional Court repeats it to Parliament in the same words: the liberty of those held in a pre-removal detention centre still has no law describing its limits. Judgment no. 193 introduces no new rules and, procedurally, leaves things as they were: validations relating to protection applications submitted before 12 June 2026 remain with the Court of Appeal, while the others have returned, by choice of the 2026 legislature, to the specialised court. Its value lies in the warning, which the Court renews with a precise expression: the missing rules are «all the more urgent in view of the central place of personal liberty in the constitutional design».
Last week, commenting on the directive of the Minister of the Interior of 3 November 2026 on fitness examinations for detention, we observed that it is precisely this gap that allows the administration to rewrite, by an internal act, the health safeguards of those deprived of their liberty. Judgment no. 193 confirms the diagnosis: as long as the law is silent, the manner of administrative detention remains entrusted to regulations, directives and prefectural measures, that is, to sources that the executive can change on its own. In a State governed by the rule of law this should not happen to anyone, still less to persons who are not accused of any offence.
The part on the rights of the defence, by contrast, raises some doubts. It is true that the detainee is not a defendant; but precisely because he loses his liberty without being accused of an offence, he should be entitled to safeguards that are no lesser. A lawyer who sees the file a few hours before the hearing, often without having been able to speak with the client, ensures a presence, not always an effective defence. On this the legislature can act without waiting for further rulings.
The Court has done what it could: it has said clearly where the problem lies and whose task it is to solve it. Now the responsibility lies entirely with Parliament. A law on the manner of detention, establishing the rights of the person in the centre, access to medical care, to lawyers, to family members, to communications, and the powers and limits of those who run the facilities, is not a favour to foreign nationals: it is the fulfilment of a constitutional obligation, and a guarantee of liberty for everyone.
What changes in practice
For those who are detained, and for their family members, the judgment does not change the rules of the proceedings: validation by a court remains necessary, defence counsel takes part in the hearing, and the measure must be notified in a language the person understands. One fact remains, however, of which to be aware: the actual conditions of detention, health care, visits and communications with the outside world are not governed by a law, and every difficulty should be reported immediately to the lawyer.
For the lawyer the judgment is a working tool. Since the Court has found that there is no adequate legal basis for the manner of detention, every administrative act affecting the fundamental rights of the detained person deserves rigorous scrutiny, in validation and extension hearings as in review proceedings. It is also necessary to check, for each case, the date of the protection application, because the competent court and the rules on appeal depend on it: applications prior to 12 June 2026 follow the previous rules, later ones d.l. n. 100 del 2026.
Avv. Giuseppe MARIANI
Potenza, 16 November 2026
Legislative references: arts. 3, 13, 24, 25, first paragraph, 72, first paragraph, 77, second paragraph, 102, second paragraph, and 111 Cost.; art. 14 d.lgs. 25 luglio 1998, n. 286; arts. 6 and 7 d.lgs. 18 agosto 2015, n. 142; art. 5-bis d.l. 17 febbraio 2017, n. 13, converted by l. 13 aprile 2017, n. 46; arts. 16, 17, 18, 18-bis and 19 d.l. 11 ottobre 2024, n. 145, converted by l. 9 dicembre 2024, n. 187; arts. 14 and 17 d.l. 12 giugno 2026, n. 100, converted by l. 7 agosto 2026, n. 145.
Precedents cited: Corte cost., sentt. n. 193 del 2026, n. 78 del 2026, n. 205 del 2025 and n. 96 del 2025; Corte cost., ord. n. 30 del 2024.
The commentary is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific case.